Author Archives: sandeepgodboleblog

Dakkhan Daad Deti Hai – How Maharashtra Nurtured Hindustani Classical Music

Music permeates all dimensions of our Indian cultural existence and expression. There are songs for every social and cultural situation. Musical talent stays with oneself for life and is an unending source of joy. Music across the regions have their nuances; some culturals are boisterous, some expressive, others soft while some have music rooted deep inside their existence. Maharashtra and its culture has music deeply ingrained. Maharashtra is the land of the brave. For many centuries it was under foreign rule. Even after winning back and ruling most parts parts of the country, it was a struggle for survival against enemies. Maharashtra therefore in the last thousand years never had the stability needed to pursue arts. This need had been fulfilled by its long tradition of saint-poets whose devotional compositions were sung by commoners and minstrels across the land. Powada- or songs with a heroic fervor were composed and popular. Shahirs or poets were known to compose Lavanis that embodied the amorous expression too. The Indian (Hindustani) Classical Music however was the preserve or forte of the northern parts of India. Maharashtra did not possess the time, resources or environment then to support, develop and curate the intensive classical art form. Winds of change were however seen in the nineteenth century. In just over hundred years the situation was to soon turn on its head. This very region was to be the stage, platform, audience, teacher and support system for Hindustani Classical Music. Hence Maharashtra or Deccan played its role more than adequately in the popularising and re-establishing the art in the new era. Here I refer not to the boundaries of the present day state of Maharashtra but to the larger area culturally influenced by it.

The first decades of the 1800s was a tumultuous era. Marathas were among the last powers to stand up to the British. Soon the entire country was to come under the British sway. Society and social structures were undergoing fundamental changes. Delhi throne was history, princely states that had accepted British authority were the new places of patronage for the arts and the artists. Maharashtra had a few princely states however they were generally smaller compared to many others in the country. The largest among the princely states in Maharashtra was Kolhapur. Their smaller size and modest means were made up more than adequately by the progressive outlook and support to art, education, enterprise and scholarship, offered by most of these princely states.

Gwalior then was considered the powerhouse of music. The region that produced a gem like Tansen in the past was the reservoir of talent and guiding light for musicians. Far away in Maharashtra, south of the Vindhyas, attraction to reach Gwalior and learn from the best ustad and guru of music lingered in the minds that were enchanted by the urge to learn music. Traveling to Gwalior and learning music was no easy task for there were multiple impediments. Society in general and families in particular did not encourage their own ones to take up music. Musicians though admired for their performance were socially not a respected for their profession. The social norms of the era and the habits as well as lifestyle of the musicians were equally responsible for this lack of honour. Hence for many of the young boys who wanted to master music in many ways were mavericks, swimming against the social norms. Families did not approve of their intention and the young boys often ran way from their homes in search of the gurus who were at the far-away fabled lands. The journey from Maharashtra to Gwalior and other places in northern India was by no means easy. The boys had no money in their pockets. The journey across the mighty rivers and Vindhyas was on foot if no means or money were available. Alas many of the gurus of that era had a peculiar temperament and really tested their students resolve. Students were at the mercy of their guru in all aspects. Gurus had their own inhibitions about sharing their musical knowledge with an open mind. The gurus would not know that despite their own reluctance and inhibitions, these young boys would be maintaining their art.

The Early Generation

Among the boys who undertook this journey was a young Vasudeo Joshi from Nagaon in Thane District. Considering that he lived till 1890, it may be reasonable to assume that he may have been born in second or third decade of the 1800s. Vasudevbua trudged his way to Gwalior and became a disciple of the great Hassu Khan himself.

The Gwalior Gharana story begins with Nathan Peerbaksh. His son Kadar Baksh had three sons Natthu, Haddu and Hassu Khan to whom he taught music This was the beginning of Gwalior Gharana in its modern avtaar. Nathan Peerbaksh was also the ustad or teacher of Ghagge Khuda Baksh who had a defect in his voice hence was called ‘Ghagge’. Through perseverance, hard work over many years, Nathan Peerbaksh tutored him into a fine artist. Ghagge Khuda Baksh is considered the founder of Agra Gharana. Nathan Peerbaksh can thus be credited to tutoring the doyens of two distinct gharana – Gwalior and also Agra. It was this Nathan Peerbaksh’s son Hassu Khan who himself tutored Vasudevbua Joshi.

Another early name from Maharashtra is that of Ramkrishnadev Paranjape known popularly as Devjibua. He was a lad from Pune. It was the era when Bajirao-II was banished to Brahmavarta or Bithoor near Kanpur. Ramkrishnadev’s maternal uncle had moved to Brahmavarta with Bajirao-II. The young boy joined his uncle at Brahmavarta. At the court of Bajirao-II was a Dhrupad singer named Chintaman Mishra. It is said that he learnt from him for twenty four years and moved to Gwalior. There he learnt under Hassu Khan. He gained renown as known as Devjibua and became a durbar singer at Gwalior. Later, he became the durbar musician at Dhar.

These pioneers from the Maharashtrian soil went north, gained musical wealth and fame. They remained part of the musical scene in North India. Though they may have toured Maharashtra later they settled in the north. It was probably natural, given that the patronage was easily available there rather than in Maharashtra. However it was not that Maharashtra was completely bereft of Indian Classical Music. The Chhatrapati durbar at Satara was probably among the first to introduce Maharashtra to khyal gayaki through a renowned singer at their service named Waris Ali. The states of Sangli, Jat, Mudhol, Kagal and few others also had dhrupad and khyal singers in their service. Nevertheless the patronage received in the north was of an entirely different magnitude.

Among the earliest khyal singers in Maharashtra was a person Mahadevbua Gokhale. Born in the village of Khol in Ratnagiri district the young Mahadev was blessed with a melodious voice. He left his home and reached Miraj. There under the patronage of Miraj ruler he started learning dhrupad under a singer there. Not fully satisfied he went to Satara where he started learning under Bapusaheb Budhkar. The guru of Bapusaheb Budhkar named Jainul Abdeen Khan was scheduled to perform a concert at the town and state of Kurundwad. The reference to Kurundwad will come again, since small towns/states like these did a lot to nurture people with the right talent. Mahadev was completely mesmerised by the singing of Jainul Abdeen and resolved to learn music under him. Mahadev along with another friend Antubua Apte ( possible name may have been Ananta – Antubua) left for Hyderabad where Jainul Abdeen Khan was based, to learn from him. For a few years Jainul Abdeen was in Maharashtra, where he was the raj gavai of Biwalkar Maharaj at Alibaug. Among his disciples were Rambhau Alibagkar, Trimbakrao Godbole. He was also at Pune for two years – there he taught Mishrabai a naikin or courtesan who was renouned for her singing. After many years of tutelage Jainul Abdeen Khan gave him permission to leave. Mahadevbua had accumulated a rich repository of a 110 raga with his commentary. He also transcribed 1200 bandish. With this musical wealth by his side, Mahadevbua left Hyderabad for Maharashtra. He was the durbar singer at various states including Miraj and Jamkhandi. Towards the end of his career he was the singer at the Kolhapur durbar. He taught music to all his four children. Towards the end of his life he came back to Miraj where he passed away at the age of eighty eight. Considering that he was born in 1813 his end would have come in 1891. The music gharana was initially known as the Miyan Gharana and later as Gokhale Gharana. Other than his four sons who continued the tradition, his disciples included – Sakaharam Sawashe, Bandopant Kolhatkar,

Dhondopant Kelkar, Naropant Jog, Ramaa Saani a naikin.This Gharana music however did not live long. Nevertheless it can be considered among the first of the established gharanas in the Deccan and Maharashtra in particular.

The Second Wave

Balkrishnabua Ichalkaranjikar – the pioneer

Classical music in Maharashtra owes a lot to Balkrishnabua Ichalkaranjikar. His efforts were representative of the ‘second wave’ where young boys enchanted by music gave everything they had to go north and gained musical knowledge. Unlike the earlier generations however who went up north and carved a name for themselves, this wave was different in that the boys and youngsters acquitted themselves well yet did not stay in the north after acquiring the knowledge. They came back to Maharashtra where they seeded this knowledge and appreciation of music in hundreds of thousands of hearts.

Balkrishnabua was born in 1849 at a village near Miraj to Rambhat Joshi of Chandur village near Ichalkaranji. Rambhat had learnt music from Balaji Bua of Satara and hence music was not alien to Balkrishnabua. Joshi were traditional profession was priesthood. Though his father wanted him to learn music, he was sent to his paternal uncle at Ichalkaranji to learn priestly duties at the age of five after he lost his mother. Balkrishna did not have much inclination or liking for priestly career and ran away from home at the age of ten in search of a guru. He tried to learn music Vishnubua Joglekar a Hardas from Mhaisal, Alidat Khan from Jat, Bhaubua Kagwadkar of Kolhapur, Wamanbua Kavthekar, Ravjibua Gogate. Though the learning progressed, Balkrishna was not satisfied with the progress achieved. Once Ravjibua spoke harsh words and insulted Balkrishna. Stung by it, Balkrishna took a vow that he would one day be a better musician than Ravjibua and only then would he return to Ichalkaranji.

Balkrishna did not have money and hence travel to North India was not easy. Often it was on foot. Steadily he reached Dhar in present day Madhya Pradesh. Dhar State was ruled by the Pawars who were originally from Maharashtra. At Dhar he became a student of Devjibua – Ramkrishnadev Paranjape, who was a good guru. Devjibua’s wife however hated Balkrishna and did her best to create hurdles whenever Devjibua taught music to Balkrishna. Enduring all the hardship and harassment, doing household chores of the family Balkrishna persisted. The hurdles and opposition reached such extremes that one day Balkrishna was left with no alternative but to quit their home and learning.

From Dhar, Balkrishna reached Gwalior. He went to Vasudeobua Joshi disciple of Hassu Khan and sought to be his student. When Vasudeobua learnt that Balkrishna had been a student of of Devjibua, Vasudeobua refused to teach him. The struggle to search for a guru started now started in an alien land. Balkrishna’s quest brought him to Kashi. Once again the paths crossed and he met Vasudeobua there. Vasudeobua had a change of heart and regretted his earlier decision of not taking him on as a student – let bygones be bygones, I will teach you music he said. Hence at last Balkrishnabua’s learning was on track again. At Gwalior Balkrishna excelled under Vasudeobua. His proficiency was outstanding and this came to the knowledge of Mohammad Khan, the son of Haddu Khan. Hassu and Haddu Khan duo,both renowned singers were sons of Kadar Baksh – Vasudeobua was student of Hassu. Mohammad Khan asked Vasudeobua to allow Balkrishna to be taught by Mohammad Khan himself. This was an honour indeed, the family of Vasudeobua’s guru wanted to teach Balkrishna ! Vasudeobua gladly released Balkrishna and this further enriched Balkrishna’s learning. Vasudeobua was a performing artist and toured across the country. He took Balkrishna along on tours across Maharashtra, Kolkata and Nepal. The tour to Nepal took toll on Vasudeobua’s health and he feel sick. A true shishya, Balkrishnabua nursed him till the end and earned the blessings of his guru. After the death of the guru, Balkrishnabua decided to return to Maharashtra.

At Miraj, with the help of Rajesaheb of Miraj he started a music school. Gundubua Aundhkar who he lovingly referred as Gundamaharaj, Vishnu Digambar Paluskar, Anant Manohar Joshi, Wamanbua Chafekar, Shridhar Balwant Pendse, Shrikrishna Herlekar, Neelkanthbua Jangam,were his disciples here. The credit of popularising the khyal gayaki in Maharashtra goes primarily to Balkrishnabua. Before his efforts, it was primarily Dhrupad that was popular in Maharashtra. The period between 1875 to 1895 was the peak years of his popularity in Maharashtra and he was in great demand. We see many Classical recitals ending with a devotional rendition or bhakti rachana. this practice was started by Balkrishnabua. He also started teaching music at at Satara in 1877 at Satara since he joined Satara Durbar. He came to Mumbai in 1882 where he established his Gaayan Samaj. The samaj had students like Sir Ramkrishna Bhandarkar, Justice Telang. Along with his Sitar player friend Vishwanath Kale, Balkrishnabua started magazine Sangeet Darpan. It most likely would have been the first periodical in India dedicated to music. Balkrishnabua suffered from asthama hence could not continue for long at Mumbai.

For a while he was at the durbar at Aundh near Satara. He relocated to Miraj since medical treatment for asthama was available with Rajesaheb of Miraj. He later moved to Ichalkaranji where he continued his mission of teaching music. Balkrishnabua’s students spanned different generations – from his early student Ganpatibua Bhilawdikar to his last shishya Yashwantbua Mirashi. His efforts saw many taking a liking to classical music. It can be said that Balkrishnabua was the one who brought and seeded the Gwalior Gharana gayaki in Maharashtra. In 1896 – a very intelligent student of his – V D Paluskar left quietly to chart a different yet impactful path. Though it may have seemed a serious setback, it was infact the beginning of a great new chapter that enriched music and Gwalior Gharana.

The Virtuous Rebound

Pandit Vishnu Digambar Paluskar

Vishnu Digambar Paluskar was born on 18 Aug 1872 at Kurundwad, a small princely state not too far away from Sangli-Miraj. His father was a kirtankar. The young Vishnu was a bright student, however an accident occurred when Vishnu was lighting fireworks. The accident permanently damaged his eyesight and thus his school education came to a halt. Vishnu was a good singer and blessed with a melodious voice. The Rajesaheb of Kurundwad arranged for his music education at Miraj under Balkrishnabua Ichalkaranjikar. At Miraj also the young Vishnu earned the affection and support of the Rajesaheb of Miraj. For nine years Vishnu learned under his guru Balkrishnabua Ichalkaranjikar and was among his popular students. One day in 1896 he left Miraj requesting leave for a few days on a pretext. However he had left not to return, at least in the immediate future till his vision was realised. Paluskar was driven by a mission to ensure that music receives respectability it deserved. Those days musicians were were not given their respected status in society. Music was performed either at the kings court or at the courtesan’s parlors. Becoming a singer, musician or performer was not considered favourably by respected families. Paluskar wanted to change people’s outlook towards music and musical performances. To achieve that he knew that discipline, sobriety, a methodical approach and spotless character in music education and and also personal standards was essential.

After leaving Miraj he traveled to different towns and cities – Aundh, Satara, Pune, Mumbai and onward to Baroda. He got an opportunity to perform in front of Maharani Jamnabai-saheb who was thoroughly impressed. Paluskar was was requested to stay at Baroda longer. At Jamnabai’s recommendation he was invited to perform at many places including some princely states. He was bestowed with gifts and money and could have led a prosperous life. However he was on a mission that was much bigger than earning money and prosperity for himself. He traveled across the country – Gujarat, Rajasthan, Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Kashmir and performed at various places. Paluskar’s guru Balkrishnabua had brought music from Gwalior to Maharashtra – Paluskar was now completing the circle, he was going northwards to show how the Deccan Pandits sing ! He stayed at Mathura for 7-8 months. Learnt the Brajbhasha and Hindi language and diction. At Aligarh his barber who was a bit knowledgeable about music told him that music can be documented using music notations and also told him about Sanskrit texts about music. Though it was his barber who told him, it was a brilliant idea. Rote learning was the only method used to tech music till then ! Paluskar developed the idea further and this enabled formal music learning. Paluskar was a staunch nationalist and did not take kindly to the British rule. However in the field of music it did not stop him in discussions and insights on western music from band master Mr James at Jodhpur.

On 5 May 1901 at Lahore, he established the Gandharva Mahavidyalaya. This was an revolutionary milestone in the world of music and music learning. It was now possible to learn music for ordinary people without having to tend to the whims of the gurus. The idea was scorned by traditionalists. How can music be taught in this manner they said. In 1916 at the Baroda Conference Atiya Begum sniggered and asked – How many Tansen did you create in your school. Paluskar said – ‘Tansen himself was unable to create another Tansen, who then am I. However I have done something that Tansen could not do. I created thousands of ‘Kansen’ in society.’ He was so correct, for Tansen to thrive, thousands of Kansen are needed.

Another individual did some path-breaking work in music – He was Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande. Paluskar was as an artist who harnessed thinking and logic to codify musical knowledge. On the other hand Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande was a thinker who searched for the grammar behind music. Bhatkhande was elder to Paluskar by about twelve years having being born on 10 Aug 1860. Both Paluskar and Bhatkhande were walking their own paths. In 1897, Paluskar had done something unthinkable for the era. At Rajkot he organised his concert with ticket sale for attendance. This something unheard, tickets and music concert ! Even Paluskar’s guru Balkrishnabua was surprised and disapproved it. Bhatkhande however liked and supported Paluskar’s idea. Paluskar wanted that such a concert be organised even in Mumbai, when it was organised Bhatkhande purchased ticket and attended the concert. In fact he became a regular patron.

Pandit Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande

Bhatkhande and Paluskar had attempted to collaborate also. Bhatkhande proposed that he would deliver a lecture weekly at Paluskar’s Gandharva Mahavidyalaya in Mumbai on a selected raga and follow it up with a performance. Paluskar was generally supportive of this idea but wanted some changes to the format. Both disagreed on the specifics, one small thing led to another, each one stayed firm on own idea and that unfortunately ruined possibilities of future collaboration and dialog. B R Deodhar, a student who had studied at Gandharva Mahavidyalaya under Paluskar and also studied under Bhatkhande was a a kind of bridge connecting the two Vishnu !

Like Paluskar, Bhatkhande also charted his path motivated by the need to codify and structure music with a view to promote and teach music. In 1918 at Gwalior he established Madhav Sangeet Vidyalaya, with backing of the Maharaja. The Ganga had reversed its flow. Earlier students from Maharashtra trudged upto Gwalior to learn. Now it was the turn of Maharashtra or Deccan to teach music to Gwalior. A music school, run by a person from the Deccan having a curriculum and texts was a great shift that was resented by the traditionalists.

On 16 Sep 1926, at Kaiserbaug, Lucknow, in the presence of Governor, Sir William Morris Bhatkhande established a music school. It was named Morris Music College. First principal was Madhavrao Joshi.

Till 1927 Bhatkhande resided at Lucknow and was involved in the teaching activities. There was a good response and in search of bigger location the the Music College was located to the old Govt building at Kaiserbaug Road in 1928. Among the students from the College who later became famous were Dhurjatiprasad Mukherji and Pahadi Sanyal. Among the nest known disciples of Bhatkhande was Shrikrishna Narayan alias Annasaheb Ratanjankar. Co-incidentally during his younger days, Annasaheb studied under Antubua Joshi who was guru-bandhu of Vishnu Digambar. Annasaheb had also studied Agra Gharana music under Ustad Faiyyaz Khan at Baroda, at the recommendation of Bhatkahnde. Annasaheb Ratanjankar served as the Principal of Morris College (later renamed as Bhatkhande Sangeet Sansthan) for many years and carried the legacy of Pandit Bhatkhande forward. Among Ratanjankar disciples were S C R Bhat, K G Ginde, Dinkar Kaikini, Sumati Mutatkar.

Ramkrushnabua Vaze

Another early pioneer from Maharashtra was Ramkrushnabua Vaze born on 28 November 1871 at Vazare in Sindhudurg District of today. He initially studied under Vithoba-anna Hadap of Malwan. At Kagal Balwantrao Pohore was durbar singer under whom he studied. The quest to learn music made Ramkrushnabua take the arduous journey to Gwalior via Pune and Mumbai, much on it on foot. At Gwalior he became the student of Nisar Hussain Khan. The guru or ustad of that era were a different lot. Learning from them and endearing to their whims was not easy. What could have been learnt in 5 years took 12-15 years since in the first four years guru taught only 4 cheeza. During his times Vazebua’s records were quite popular. He had the honour of being appointed the court musician of Nepal. Among his disciples were Keshavrao Bhosale, Bapurao Pendharkar, Dinanath Mangeshkar and Vinayakrao Patwardhan.

Bhaskarbua Bakhale

Bhaskar later the renouned Bhaskarbua Bakhale was born on 17 Oct 1869 and spent childhood days at the Baroda Sansthan. The young Bhaskar following and supporting Vishnubua Pimpalkhare a singer-kirtankar there. On hearing about this talented boy, Maharaja Sayajirao Gaikwad had him enrolled in the ‘Gayan-shala’ of the sansthan. Maula Baksh was the guru of this establishment. In 1884 his performance at the annual function of this music school caught wide attention. The news reached Annasaheb Kirloskar who decided to enlist the young boy into his natak-company. Bhaskar joined the company and he was doing well, when his voice was impacted as he came of age. His efforts to get it back in control were mocked at ang the young Bhaskar felt the pain and insult. Bhaskar vowed – until this Bhaskar becomes Bhaskarbua will not show my face and saying so he left the Kirloskar Natak Company.

He went back to Baroda and stayed with his sister Tanibai. Nyayaratna Telang was a prominent citizen was his well-wisher entrusted him to the raj-gayak of Baroda Faiz Mohammed Khan. Faiz Mohammad had been a shagird of the legendary Kadarbaksh, the father of Hassu and Haddu Khan who brought fame to Gwalior Gharana and ustad of Gagge Khudabaksh who is credited with being the fountainhead of the Agra Gharana. First few months at Faiz Mohammed were a waste since Faiz Mohammed did not tech him much. When Telang came to know of the situation he intervened and that was when his training really started. This training laid the solid foundation of Bhaskarbua’s gayaki. He was a sangam of music gharanas. – he learnt how to present a cheez and alaap from Faiz Mohammed Khan, from Natthan Khan Agrewale it was laykaari and bol-taan, and from Alladiya Khan it was minute, intricate and hidden gayaki that he imbibed.

Bhaskarbua with student Bal Gandharva, Lokmanya Tilak seen to the right (from Amit Paranjape’s Tweet)

He had a fan following from across Karnataka, Maharashtra, Sindh, Punjab and Kashmir. In fact his title Dev-Gandharva was earned when in Punjab where he had a huge following. The renowned sarangi player Zande Khan accompanied him in his first recital itself. Alia- Fattu, Miya Jaan, great names of the Patiala Gharana by themselves, were others performers of caliber who had done his sangat. It is said that Bhaskarbua’s gayaki impressed Zande Khan so much that he had tears in his eyes and after his recital laid the sarangi at Bhaskarbua’s feet.

Bhaskarbua had been a student of music across different gharanas and that indeed was his uniqueness atleast at that point in time when loyalty to a gharana was supreme. He thus imbibed specialties across different gharana. Among his students were Bal Gandharva, Master Krishnarao, Tarabai Shirodkar, Gundopant Walawalkar and others. He also taught Kesarbai Kerkar for sometime. His contribution in the form of an institution – Bharat Gayan Samaj at Pune through which music teaching is alive and thriving to this day was his great gift to popularising music. Till his very end in 1922 he continued his apprenticeship with Alladiya Khan with whom he shared a very warm relationship.

In addition to Paluskar and Bhatkhande there was a third Vishnu was was instrumental in Maharashtra’s music journey. More popularly known for this pioneering work in entirely different area, this Vishnu was a accomplished musician. Vishnupant Chhatre is known as the father of the Indian Circus world. Vishnupant Chhatre’s father was an employee of the Jamhandi State. The young Vishnu since childhood was fond of animals and his hobby was to teach his animal friends to do some tricks. He was also fond music though he had not formally studied music. Vishnu was employed as Chabukswar ( at the stables) at the Ramdurg Sansthan. Once, at Kurundwad Vishnu and his few friends were together in an informal maifal. At the prodding of his friends Vishnu sang but not so well. Dattopant Phadke his friend, a Veena artist remarked that ‘Vishnu, you will never be able to sing in your own life’. Vishnu took it up as a challenge and vowed ‘Will go the north, learn music and teach you music, this is my challenge’. He left his job and reached Gwalior. He went to Sardar Babasaheb Apte – leading horse expert. When asked about his objective, Vishnu said ‘I will learn Ashwa-vidya for a living and music as my hobby’. He became a shishya of the great Haddu Khan. It so happened that he was traveling with Haddu Khan and his family in a boat across a river. The river was in spate and the boat want into a spin. Vishnupant braved his life and saved Haddu Khan’s family. After this incident Vishnu became is most favoured disciple.

Vishnupant Chhatre

Around 1882 Vishnupant was challenged by a few rulers when the circus of Mr Wilson performed. Vishnupant took the challenge and started his own circus. It was the first Indian circus. In 1892 when the circus was touring Kashi he heard of an auliya sheltered by a Brahmin Family. The person begged for alms but was an amazing singer. Vishnupant out of curiosity wanted to see for himself. He was shocked to see that the person was none other than Rahimat Khan his guru bandhu and the extremely talented son of his guru Haddu Khan. Vishnupant told that Brahmin that he is in a position to look after Rahimat Khan and will take care of him his whole. Vishnupant brought a lot of stability and direction to Rahimat Khan’s life. He took care of him. Vishnupant used to provide the stimulus in his mehfils in the form of assisting him on the tanpura, at times when needed, he used to take care of him as a young child would need. Vishnupant was a patient guardian who used to manage Rahimat Khans whims in a mature manner. Rahimat Khans addiction to opium was an irritant, however it was managed to the best possible extent. Rahimat Khan used to address Vishnupant as ‘dada’.

Rahimat Khan did many mehfils in Mumbai at respected locations including bungalows of the rich and famous like Nana Shankarshet himself. Vishnupant had saved the Gwalior Gharana gayaki twice – once when he brought Haddu Khan’s boat to safety and the other when he brought back Rahimat Khan back into civilised world ! Rahimat Khan was probably the first among the singers from the north to settle in Maharashtra. There would be many more.

New Harbour of the Gharanas – Maharashtra

With social changes and changes to the systems that patronised music, newer centers emerged as foremost centers of musical learning and performance. Earlier the durbars in the north were great supporters of music and most singers and musicians depended on its patronage. This were gradually changing, wealthy business people and common citizens were the new class of patrons. The Sangeet Natak over decades had gradually created an informed audience for Classical Music in Maharashtra. The comparatively liberal social environment meant that the taboo associated with learning music among the educated classes was gradually diminishing. The Mumbai, Pune, Goa, Sangli, Miraj, Dharwad region was already fertile with so many talented people taking to music. It was thus a very natural progression that the epicenter of music from across the country moved to the Deccan or Maharashtra.

The musical world had indeed come a full cycle. The migration continued for a long time. Among those who moved into Maharashtra were Nissar Hussain Khan of Gwalior gharana, Alladiya Khan of Jaipur Gharana, Abdul Karim Khan, Niyaz Ahmed Khan and Faiyyaz Ahmed Khan brothers of Kirana Gharana, Vilayat Hussain Khan of Agra Gharana and Bade Ghulam Ali Khan of Patiala Gharana who had migrated from Pakistan. The great maestro of Jaipur Gharana Alladiya Khan Saheb used to say ‘Uttar paida karti hain, magar Dakkan daad deti hain.’It was Maharashtra that soon became the ashraysthan of music – Miraj, Kurundwad, Kolhapur, Ichalkaranji, Pune, Mumbai became the musical towns and cities. The singers and musicians from North Indian who settled here also made Maharashtra their own home. Marathi people, language, traditions, culture, literature, music, theater, they appreciated it all and wove it in their lives here. The people and their disciples also opened up their hearts. Thus they never wished to return back to the north.

Gwalior Gharana

The Gwalior Gharana is considered the mothership of many other musical Gharanas. It was this Gharana that fascinated the first generation of young lads from Maharashtra who braving odds went to the north and Gwalior in particular. Nathan Peerbaksh is considered the progenitor of Gwalior Gharana. For three to four generations after him Gwalior remained the key location where doyens of the Gharana were generally based. Noted composer and music scholar and critic, Shri Keshavrao Bhole said ‘Balkrishnabua, Vazebua and Bakhale shifted the shravan-bhumi and karma bhumi of khyal gayaki to Maharashtra.’ These three masters endured great hardships to study music from temperamental gurus and hence they suffered as lot. However this realisation ensured that they did not commit these mistakes and spread music knowledge with an open heart and mind. This tradition of the mercurial gurus was also ended by these stalwarts.

Agra Gharana

Gagge Khudabaksh (1790-1880) is considered the originator of the Agra Gharana. The prefix Gagge was meant to indicate his defective voice. Tired of the constant insults and remarks he went to Gwalior to Natthan Peerbaksh ( Hassu-Haddu Khan were his grandchildren). Natthan Peerbaksh told Khudabaksh to learn khyal rather than Dhrupad given the infirmities in his voice. Peerbaksh’s advice provided much needed solace to Khudabaksh. He said that this would be tough however results would follow. After learning and practicing for twelve years Khudabakhsh returned to Agra. He blended the original Dhrupad style with Gwalior Khyal style. This synthesis led to the Agra Gharana of Khyal gayaki. Natthan Peerbaksh was in a sense the guru of two gharanas – His grandchildren Haasu and Haddu Khan became the originators of Gwalior gayaki while his shishya Gagge Khudabaksh became the fountainhead of Agra gayaki.

Mumbai first got exposure to Agra Gayaki when Sher Khan, nephew of Gagge Khudabaksh traveled here. Sher Khan liked the city and was here for eight years. The first Agra musician to create shishya in Maharashtra was Natthan Khan – Sher Khan’s son. Natthan Khan was trained by Ghulam Abbas. Three distinguished disciples trained by Ghulam Abbas were his grandson (daughters’s son) Faiyyaz Khan , Natthan Khan and Natthan Khan’s son Vilayat Hussein Khan. Natthan Khan was at Jaipur in the initial period.

Natthan Khan who had came to Baroda and the Maharaja showered him with respect and riches. It was here that Natthan Khan was introduced to the young Bhaskar (bua) Bakhale who became his disciple here. Bhaskarbua later moved to Mumbai with Natthan Khan. The Mysore Durbar appointed Natthan Khan as the Raj-Gavai. Natthan Khan showered Bhaskarbua with immense love and affection the like his own son. Natthan Khan left this world on 1901. Before he died he instructed Bhaskarbua to continue training under Alladiya Khan of Jaipur Gharana.

Ustad Faiyyaz Khan

Faiyyaz Khan was another popular singer of Agra Gharana in Maharashtra . From his late fathers side he was from the Rangile Gharana. However since his father Sabdar Hussein Khan died before he was born, his mother moved back to her father Ghulam Abbas Khan, who taught him music. In 1906 when in his twenties Mysore Maharaja had honoured Faiyyaz Khan with a gold medal. From 1912 he became the Durbar gayak of Baroda Court. Faiyyaz Khan had a soft corner for Maharashtra and Mumbai.

Son of Natthan Khan – Mohammad Khan, Bhaskarbua Bakhale, Bablibai Parkar, Unus Khan son of Vilayat Hussein Khan, his newphews Khadim Hussein Khan and Latif Hussein Khan were all residents of Mumbai Vilayat Hussein Khan not only stayed but also developed a loving association with the people and language. Learning Marathi was his hobby. He used to carry a small notebook where he used to note down a cheez or a new Marathi word. He used to write letter to his students in Marathi.

Vilayat Hussein Khan taught many students during his life. Indirabai Wadkar, Saraswatibai Fatarphekar, Shrimatibai Narvekar, Vatsalabai Parvatkar, Ramabai Honawarkar, Gajananbua Joshi, Jagannathbua Purohit, Ratnakant Ramnathkar, Sitaram fataphekar, D V Kane, Dattubua Ichalkaranjikar were among his shishya.

Jagannathbua was among close shishya with whom he had an endearing association since 1930. Jagannathbua also had a large number of shishya to whom he gave generously in the same manner. Ram Marathe, Manik Varma, C R Vyas, Suresh Haldankar, Jitendra Abhisheki, Yashwantbua Joshi, Balakram Jadhav, G N Joshi, Vasantrao Kulkarni, Nirmala Gogate, Prabhudev Sardar, Malati Pande were among them.

Kirana Gharana

Ustad Abdul Karim Khan

Abdul Karim Khan was born on 11 Nov 1872 at place called Kirana near Shamli in the present day Uttar Pradesh. Abdul Karim Khan is considered the founder of the Kirana Gharana. He came from a family was from a family of string instrument musicians. His father was Kale Khan and his brother’s name wa Abdul Latif. The greatest musical impact on him was that of Bhoo-Gandharva Rahimat Khan of Gwalior Gharana. The walls separating the gharanas did not impact him and he was a keen lerner across the different gharanas. Even the north-south divide was something he did not care. Later in life hen he was in Karnataka,he studied Karnataka music from Ambabai, Gangubai Hangal’s mother.

It was not an easy era for the Kirana Gharana as many so called experts and purists scoffed saying that it was a gharana not that of singers but of musical instrument players. Khansaheb set off in his youth after learning music of his gharana. He was in the service of the Court of Baroda for three years as the Raj Gavai. Around1898 he arrived in Maharashtra. He was based in Mumbai for a while but soon thereafter established himself at Miraj. The same Miraj that has seen the migration of Vishnu Digambar in 1896 from there to north India, was enriched by the arrival of an exceptional musician in jut a few years. Abdul Karim Khan developed his own unique style of rendering thumri. Jamuna ke teer, Piya ke mila ki aas, Piyabin nahi were among his most loved thumri’s among the listeners. Fortunately the recording are available even today. Not just a musician or performer, Abdul Karim Khan was an expert musicologist. He could produce the 27 shruti used in different ragas. Abdul Karim Khan had written a book – Swar Prakash – for Arya Sangeet Vidyalay.

At Miraj he used to perform gayan sewa at Khwaja Mirasaheb Darga. His son Sureshbabu Mane received initial music training from him.His students included Ananatrao Gadgil, Sawai Gandharva, Dashrathbua Mulay, Balkrishnabua Kapileshwari, Rosha Ara Bagum, Behere bua.

During October 1937 he traveled to present day Chennai where he performed at a grand mehfil. After the success he was scheduled to perform at Pondicherry where Yogi Arvind was to be present. On the way there on 27 Oct 1937, during the train journey from Chennai he felt uncomfortable hence alighted at one of the stations. A bed was laid at the station itself however he understood that it was the final calling. He washed his hand and feet, prayed and started performing the Durbari raag. His end came the way he lived his entire life, singing and worshiping music.

Rambhau Kundgolkar, popularly known as Sawai Gandharva, Abdul Karim Khan’s disciple taught students who became illustrious singers. Pandit Bhimsen Joshi, originally from Gadag was among his best known students. Bhimsen Joshi is the recipient of India’s highest civilian awards the Bharat Ratna. Other famous students included Firoz Dastur, Gangubai Hangal, Basavraj Rajguru. Though a relatively newer gharana in its antiquity, has been a very popular gharana in Maharashtra.

Jaipur Gharana

Among the various music paths that reached Maharashtra, one started from a place called Uniyara, a small principality near Jaipur. Alladiya Khan was the king-pin in Maharashtra of the Jaipur Gharana. Alladiya was born on Aug 10,1855 in a family deeply seeped in music. His father Mohammad Khan was a singer at the court of Maharaja Fattesingh of Uniyara.

Alladiya Khan Saheb

Alladiya lost his father when he was 15 years. His fathers cousin Jehangir Khan took him under his tutelage. After three years they relocated to Udaipur where Jehangir Khan’s brother Chimman Khan was a durbar singer. For a period Alladiya was in Jaipur where Jehangir Khan was durbar singer. There he was exposed to the music of doyens – Haddu and Hassu Khan of Gwalior Gharana, Agrewale Ghugge Khudabaksh, Taanras Khan, Mubarak Ali Khan, Grandson of Miyan Manrang – Mohammad Ali Khan, Guru of Jaipur Maharaja Haider Baksh and his brother Ali Baksh, tabla player Amaan Ali Khan, Veena player Vazir Khan, satariye Imratsen and Imdad Khan.

After Udaipur Jehangir Khans family moved to Ratlam and then Mandsaur. Alladiya was proving himself well and his guru started concentrating even more on his talim. He is not just my nephew but my shishya and son, Jehangir Khan used to say.

Alladiya Khan traveled extensively and performed at various durbars of various princely states in India. In 1895 he came to Kolhapur as the durbar singer. He was in Kolhapur till 1922 after which he moved to Mumbai.

The greatness of Alladiya was that he created a new style that imbibed aspects of Dhrupad Dhamar and Khyal. Thus he gave Maharashtra and the country a new gharana – Jaipur Gharana. Bhaskarbua Bakhale was his dear student (d 1922), Tanibai Ghorpade (Kolhapur d 1931), Lakshmibai Jadhav, Govindrao Shaligram, Mogubai Kurdikar, Kesarbai Kerkar were his shishya. Alladiya Khan along with, his brother Haider Khan (d 1936), sons Manji Khan (d 1937) and Bhurji Khan were the doyens of the Jaipur Gharana. Bhurji Khan had received training for two years from Jehangir Khan who was guru to Alladiya. Manji and Bhurji Khan jugalbandi were very popular. With Manji Khan death the last performers in the family lineage was no more. After Manji, it was left to Bhurji Khan to take the legacy of the gharana forward. He trained Mallikarjun Manoor, Wamanrao Sadolokar, Dhondutai Kulkarni, Menakabai Shirodkar, Lakshmibai Jadhav, Madhusudan Kanetkar, Madhukar Sadolikar among his students.

Till Alladiya was alive he continued to spread knowledge. Leela Shirgaonkar, Gulubhai Jasdanwala were among whom he taught. Mogubai Kurdikar and Kesarbai Kerkar, his students was well known singers and among the earliest female singers who carved a niche for themselves. Alladiya Khan lived a long life. He died on 16 March 1946. His long life also meant that he was an unfortunate witness to many of his dear ones including gifted performers from his family as well as exceptional students like Bhaskarbua departing before his own death.Unfortunately Alladiya Khans recordings are not available.

The Jaipur-Atrauli Gharana prospered in Maharashtra due to the talented students including Kamaltai Tambe, Kishori Amonkar, Suresh Haldankar, Padma Talwalkar, Jitendra Abhisheki, Ulhas Kashalkar, Shruti Sadolikar, Arti Anklikar and so many more.

Bhendi Bazar Gharana

The Bhendi Bazar Gharana other than the extinct Gokhale Gharana is probably the only gharana that can be identified with a name from Maharashtra. Three sons of Ustad Dilawar Khan from Bijnour near Muradabad – Chhaju, Nazeer and Khadim Hussein received initial music training from their father. They set off to learn more and make a career. They enriched themselves as students of Ustad Inayat Hussein Khan of Rampur Sahaswan. Then learnt Jaipur Dagar Gharana Dhrupad from Inayat Khan In the decade of 1870 the brothers reached Mumbai. The name Bhendi Bazar has an interesting origin. The area was referred to as ‘behind the bazaar’ by the Britishers who were the masters of Mumbai. The name corrupted itself in ‘Bhendi Bazar’ when pronounced by the locals. As the brothers were based in this area, the music gharana inherited this name.

Anjanibai Malpekar

Anjanibai Malpekar was among the first able disciple of the gharana who led it onward. Born on 22 April 1883 at Malpe in Goa, the family relocated to Mumbai when she was 8 years along with her younger sister Kamla, with a view to develop develop their music talent and career. At the recommendation of Pandit Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande who was known to her father, Nazeer Khan agreed to teach the Malpekar sisters. The tution started well till the cruel plague took away Kamla from this world and also Nazeer Khan’s son Mubarak Ali. The Khan brothers regained composure after this tragedy and decided to concentrate on Anjani. For three and a half years they taught her raag Yaman and one and half year was invested in studying Bhairavi ! Anjani also helped Bhatkhande in his quest to collect and curate music bandish. Anjanibai gave up music performances even before reaching the age of forty years, after 1922, at the advice of her spiritual guru Shri Narayan Maharaj of Kedgaon. During her era women singers performed standing, Anjanibai declared ( she was just 16 years then) that she will not stand and perform sitting down like male singers. Anjanibai was also acclaimed for her beauty and posed as a model for famous painters like M V Dhurandhar and Raja Ravi Verma. Her students included names like Begum Akhtar, Naina Devi and Kumar Gandharva.

Amaan Ali was the son of Chhaju Khan but not very serious about music. Anjani bai goaded him to be sincere about learning music and putting his talent to good use. Amaan Ali’s outlook changed thereafter for the better as he developed into an expert and knowledgeable musician. He was more interested in the musical knowledge rather than performances. His disciples included Shivkumar Shukla, Vasantrao Deshpande, Lata Mangeshkar. Trimbakrao Janorikar was also attracted to Amaan Ali’s music. Though Janorikar had learnt the Gwalior Gharana music for 12 years, he became a shishya of Amaan Ali also. Janorikar continued to teach the Bhendi Bazaar Gayaki. Among the later generation artists are Suhasini Koratkar, Anuradha Kuber and Sharad Karmarkar.

May Music Continue to Prosper

The second half of the nineteenth century and the twentieth century saw a great resurgence of Indian Classical Music. The discipline moulded itself into a more systematic and structured performing art. It was a period of great political and social change. Maharashtra and the Deccan provided the fertile ground for nurturing Indian Classical Music. Experts, students, practitioners and audience were all here in this geographical region. It provided a much needed boost to retain, maintain and evolve the disciple to a vibrant and living art form. Music transcends barriers and boundaries. No region can claim exclusive domination of music for any reason. Maharashtra has been an enabler and contributor to the musical journey, and it would be worthwhile to acknowledge this credit that Maharashtra deserves. More than warming the cockles of any heart, this will help to gain insights so that our country can preserve out musical heritage and see to move even higher on its road to prosperity.

References:

Gaan-Yogi Pandit D V Paluskar by Anjali Kirtane (Marathi)

Sangeet Shastra Parichay – Anand Godse (Marathi)

Autobiography – Keshavbua Ingale translated by Gouri Ghorpadey

Heritage Shri Ram Temple of Pune

The Temple City

Pune is a city of Gods and Temples. Many Deities have temples dedicated to them. This article explores the heritage Shri Ram Temples in Pune that go back to the Peshwa period or earlier based on the historical records that I have been able to access. Pune then was a relatively small town compared to the huge expanse it has transformed into today. Pune was located on the southern bank of the Mutha River (northen bank comprising of Shivajinagar, Deccan Gymkhana was not part of Pune) comprising of approximately an area of four square kilometers. The nearby villages of Parvati, Bhambavde, Wananvdi, Erandwane. Ganeshkhind surrounded it. However these villages were distinct and not considered as part of Pune. In this small town there were more than three hundred shrines and temples dedicated to various Deities in the early 1800s.

The oldest temples in Pune around the16th Century were Kasba Ganpati, Tambdi Jogeshwari, Kedareshwar and the now non-existent temples of Puneshwar and Narayaneshwar. It is surprising that there was no prominent Shri Ram Temple that finds a mention among them. As late as 1774 we find no mention of a prominent Ram Mandir in Pune at all. Most of the Ram Mandirs were built in the later era of Peshwa Rule.

Tulshibaug Ram Mandir

The Tulshibaug Shri Ram Mandir is among the most prominent Ram Temples in Pune. The Temple complex is set up about an acre, quite large considering that it is quite rare to find such large land parcels in the most central part of Pune where it is located. The murtis of Shri Ram Laxman and Sita are most beautiful. At the far end of the Sabhamandap is the Daas Maruti murti made in black stone. It is easily among the most real life murtis of Maruti in Pune. The Temple was built by Naro Appaji Khire the subhedar of Pune during Madhavrao Peshwa’s time. It was during the period post Panipat when the city had grown despondent that this cheerful temple was constructed and it is very likely to have lifted the spirits of the city then. Though the Shri Ram Temple was completed in a year or two, around 1763, work on extending the temple structure and the complex continued for well over twenty five years. The Shikhar or superstructure of the temple is tall and goes up 43 meters with chhatris and upshaikhar organised in multiple layers. Till the time Mandai was built in 1885, this was the tallest structure in Pune. The Shikhar is rectangular as its base and morphs into a conical structure as it rises up. Stucco figures decorate the shikhar as it rises up. The wooden Sabha-Mandap in front of the Deities, built with timber is a very elegant structure. The high wooden ceiling is decorated with designs typical of the Peshwa era. Such decorative ceilings are referred as the ‘takhta-poshi’ meaning the embellished ceiling. The Ram Janma Utsav is very special and attracts devotees from Pune.

The beautiful murtis at Tulshibaug -pic credit Smita Deshmukh

The Two Joshi Ram Mandir

Murti at the Joshi Ram Mandir, Shaniwar Peth pic credit Abhishek Muglikar

In Pune there are two Shri Ram Mandirs with the name Joshi Shri Ram Mandir. One of them is in Shaniwar Peth about a hundred meters from the wall of the Shaniwar Wada while the other is at Kasba Peth. Two distinct Joshi Families own the two different temples. The Ram Temple at Shaniwar retains some of its Peshwa era decorative wood work in the form of decorative pillars and patti.

The beautiful ‘suru’ pillars at Joshi Ram Mandir, Kasba Peth
Murti at Joshi Ram Mandir at Kasba Peth – pic credit Abhishek Muglikar

The temple at Kasba Peth is built in stone with the typical ‘suru’ pillars. The temple has recently been renovated faithfully retaining the heritage structure.

Ram Zopdi

Ram Zopdi pic Abhishek Muglikar

Raviwar Peth has been the ‘market district’ of Pune since the last two centuries. This Peth or ward was developed by the Peshwa to attract and settle the traders in the city. Within Raviwar Peth is an area called ‘Kapad-Ganj’ meaning the ‘cloth-quarter’ that had a large number of shops trading in cloth and textiles. The Someshwar Temple is located here. In a small area within this complex is the ‘Zopdi Shri Ram’ or the ‘Ram Zopdi’ temple. Zopdi in Marathi means hut. The name is quite modest for a temple. As narrated to me by my grandfather, this temple was historically nearby, but not within the Someshwar Temple complex premises where it is located now. The temple was located nearby, modest and similar to a small hut giving the temple this name. Later for for some reasons, the temple was relocated to the Someshwar Temple complex probably over a century ago. As per the Peshwa records there is a mention of Ramachandraji Devalaya south of Mansaram Badhai house in Raviwar Peth. Badhai or carpenters were important craftsmen who helped in construction wadas or homes in Pune. The lane adjacent to the Someshwar Temple Complex is Badhai Ale or Badhai Lane where this temple was probably located earlier. The Ram Zopdi has been cared for by priests who migrated to Pune many generations ago from the northern part of India.

Ram Temple: Amruteshwar-Siddheshwar Complex

Ram Temple at the Amruteshwar Siddheshwar Temple Complex by Abhishek Muglikar

As you cross the road across the Shaniwarwada to the west and approaches the Mutha river, you can see the Amruteshwar-Siddheshwar Temple Complex of Temples. Temples of Amruteshwar, Siddheshwar, Vishnu and Shriram are located in this complex. A ‘sati’ platform in the memory of a lady from the Dhadphale family who committee sati is also seen here. The Siddheshwar temple was built by the Naik-Joshi Baramatikar, the family into which Bihubai the sister of Bajirao-I was married. This temple was built in Bihubai’s memory after her death around the mid 1700s. The Shri Ram temple here is much smaller than Amruteshwar and Siddheshwar temples located in this complex. The present structure of the Shri Ram temple seems to have been re-built much later in the modern era. The murtis of Ram Laxman and Sita are very beautiful and quite different compared to most temples. Given its proximity to the Shaniwar Wada it is very likely that the Peshwas may have visited the temple often.

Vaidya Ram Mandir

Vaidya Ram Mandir at Cholkhan Ale

The Vaidya Ram Mandir is away from sight and behind closed doors of a wada at the Khan Ale. Only those who know of it or a few knowledgeable locals may be able to find it in the busy market where it is located. Vaidya was the Peshwa vakil or representative at the court of Bhonslas of Nagpur. Vaidya had acquired the property where the temples stands to recovery an unpaid loan that they had given to a person named Vinze, the earlier owners. The murtis of these Deities were brought from Varhad or Vidarbha region in 1811. The area where the temple is located underwent a lot of changes over the two hundred years, since the temple was established. Most of the property has been converted for commercial use. The Deities continue to be installed at the original location however in a considerably smaller place.

Kala Ram Mandir

Kala Ram Temple, Pune – typical Peshwa era entrance structure.
Murti at Kala Ram Mandir

Kala Ram Mandir at Nashik is quite well known. However the Kala Ram temple at Pune is relatively unknow. Peshwa era records refer to the Ram temple in Somwar Peth. Though it was not referred to as the Kala Ram, most likely the records refers to the same temple. The entrance of the temple is typical of the late Peshwa era. Similar entrances are seen at the Khunya Murlidhar and the Kameshwar Temple. The Deities at the Kala Ram are beautiful murtis made from black coloured stone giving it the name Kala Ram. The Sabha Mandap is timber and within it stand a beautiful murti of Daas Maruti. The temple has retained the old word charm that brings peace and calm to the devotee.

Ram Mandirs in Guruwar Peth

Ram Mandir at Phulwala Chowk at Guruwar Peth Pune

Historical records mention two Shri Ram Temples in Guruwar Peth during late Peshwa era. The old historical landmarks no longer exist. However it is possible to reasonably conclude the identity of these two temples. One of the temples is located at the Phulwala Chowk and appears like a wada from the outside. There are two temples when you enter inside – one is Mahadev and the other is Shri Ram.

The other Shri Ram Temple from Guruwar Peth is most likely the Madiwale Ram Mandir. This temple at Guruwar Peth is in the same lane as the Vetal Temple. The Ram Mandir cannot be identified from outside as it is behind a modern building. Inside, the Sabhamandap is reasonably spacious despite being ensconced within the modern building. This is a private temple and open to public on Ram Navmi.

Ram Mandir at Ganj Peth

Godse’s Ram Mandir at Ganj Peth with the typical Maratha pillars
The small and beautiful murti at the Godse Ram Mandir

At Ganj Peth, in small lane that leads to Mahatma Phule Wada is a small Shri Ram Temple. The temple cannot be easily seen since the temple is located with its back to the lane. The Peshwa era document refers to the temple as the Ram Temple in Bhagwandas Bairagi Math. The temple is known locally as Godse’s Shri Ram Mandir after the family who owns the temple. As per the Godse family Bairagi was indeed the surname that the family used till a generation ago and that this temple has been with their family since a long time. The temple interiors are modest yet comfortable. Old style ‘suru’ pillars is a clear identification of the earlier era.

Ram Temple at Bhambawde Village

Ram Mandir at Shivajinagar

Historical records mention the Ram Mandir at Dwarkadas Bairagi House at Bhambawde or present day Shivajinagar. One can see a Shri Ram Temple opposite the Rokdoba Temple at the ‘gaothan’ area in Shivajinagar. It is said that this temple was established by a ‘shishyaa’ of Jangli Maharaj. Jangli Maharaj resided in an era after the Peshwas. If indeed the temple was established by the shishyaa this may not be the Deity referred in the Peshwa era document. However the possibility of the Deities existing from earlier times cannot be denied. More research would be needed to conclude on this either ways.

Akra Maruti

Akra Maruti Ram Mandir at Shukrawar Peth Pune

At Shukrawar Peth stands the Akra Maruti temple. The temple gets the name from eleven murtis of Maruti just outside the Ram Temple. The property where the temple stands was owned by Bapu Gokhale the last commander of the Maratha forces. This Ram Mandir there is not mentioned in the Peshwa era list I have referred in this article. It may be possible that the temple may have been built a few years later after the list was compiled. The temple is a simple single storied structure with Shri Ram at one end and Maruti at the other. The ambience has old era, simple, small town vibes.

Temples I have been unable to identify and locate

There is a mention of many temples from the Peshwa document that I have not been able to identify or locate. Information on these temples is given below. Information or leads should anybody know, would be most helpful and welcome.

  • Shri Ram at the wada of Naik Thatte. This Wada was at present day Laxmi Road near the City Post office. I had found reference on the Internet that the murti were moved to Subhash-nagar Pune, however I have lost that reference and unable to find the reference again. Hence unable to back this up this claim.
  • During the reign of Bajirao II there was a nobleman by the name of Rupram Choudhari. His wada was within Shukrawar Peth then and had a temple to Shri Ram and there were other Deities also. I have been able to identify possible locations of the wada. It may have been opposite the Jedhe Mansion or a bit further down the same road on the way to Panch Houd Mission. This wada was purchased by a prominent lawyer Mr Bhajekar, about a century ago. It is possible that we may be able to find somebody who may know Bhajekar Wada and thus conclusively identify the location. On the same road is a temple where Deities that find a mention as being located at Rupram Choudhari Wada, are seen. Is this merely a coincidence or were the actual Deities from the wada moved to this temple. I know not but someday I hope to find the answer.
  • At Kasba Peth there is mention of a Ram Mandir near Tatyashet Majukar House. It is difficult to identify the location based on this description. I know of two Shri Ram Temples in Kasba – one near the Kal Bhairav Temple and the other in the lane behind Kedareshwar (Chavan Ram Temple). Could it be one among them, unless there is specific information we would not be able to say.
  • At what was Shivpuri then or Rasta Peth of today there is a mention of Ram temple at Devbhat Apshingekar Wada. After more than two hundred years it would not be easy to locate it based on this description, however if we are able to identify a Shri Ram Temple near the KEM Hospital it may give us some leads for further investigation.
  • Between the Daruwala Pul of today and Raste Wada was the Nyahal or Nagesh Peth. This Peth has been subsumed into Rasta Peth since then. There is a mention of a Shri Ram and Vitthal Rakhmai Temple in close proximity there. Any leads would be worth investigating.
  • Behind the Dulya Maruti temple there is a mention of Shri Ram Temple belonging to Baba Vidwajan. I have not been able to locate the temple yet.
  • At Hanumant or Nana Peth of today is mention of a Shri Ram Temple. There is a temple at a lane parallel to Laxmi Road near the Nana Chavdi Chowk. The temple is called Maheshwari Ram in the present era. Is it the same temple, we would need to find out.
  • At the Ganeshkhind Ganpati Temple there is a mention of Ram. I have not been able to locate the Ram Mandir at the Ganpati Temple. Any inputs would be most welcome.

Other Heritage Shri Ram Temples

After the Peshwa Era too there were many Ram temples that were established. Some of them are about two hundred years old and all of them atleast a hundred years old. These include –

At Sadashiv Peth : Raste Tai Ram Mandir, Gadgil Ram Mandir, Rahalkar Ram Mandir, Pandit Ram Mandir, Sadavarte Ram Mandir

Gadgil Ram Mandir at Sadashiv Peth
Unique murti at the Rahalkar Ram Mandir at Sadashiv Peth

At Narayan Peth: Bhaji Ram, Likte Ram Mandir,

Bhaji Ram Mandir, Naraya Peth

At Shaniwar Peth: Agashe Ram Mandir

Agashe’s Ram Mandir, Shaniwar Peth

At Raviwar Peth: Sarnaik Ram Mandir

At Rasta Peth: Raste Ram Mandir

Ram Mandir at the Sardar Raste Wada

At Shukrawar Peth: Ramchandraji Temple (Naik)

Ramachandraji Mandir

The heritage temples have a stories to narrate. There is much history that awaits to be told. Stories and history that remains undiscovered or remains to be narrated decays and is also lost. Each passing moment adds to the loss. The city of Pune has lost most of the older structures that have witnessed the times gone by. It is the temples that largely remain. If we lend an ear to what the temples tell us it opens up our undiscovered or forgotten history and heritage.

A Tour to the Heritage Ganpati Temples in Pune

Ganpati Festival evokes a special feeling in Maharashtra, all the more so in its cultural capital of Pune. Many know the five ‘Manache’ or privileged Ganpati Deities worshiped during the days of the Ganesh Festival. In addition to these, there are other ‘special’ Ganpati Deities in Pune that derive a special status from their vintage or age. They have blessed the city of Pune for more than two centuries. Some of the Deities are even older.

The list of Deities from the Peshwa times from 1774 to 1810 provide insights into the Deities that are significant historically as well as from an heritage perspective. As at 1810 there were 62 Ganesh or Ganpati Deities in the city. There are temples where Ganpati has been been the main or presiding Deity at the temple. At other temples Ganesh is not the presiding Deity of the temple but is given due respect as an additional Deities in the temple. Of these 62 Ganpati that find mention, we were able to locate 45 heritage Ganpati Deities. Most of the Deities are from from the Peshwa list mentioned above. A few are not in the list but are believed from historical times. Ashwin Gandhi, Ajey Godbole, Sonali Malvankar and myself, we set out on our cycles to discover the Heritage Ganpati Temples. We enjoyed this discovery, hope you would enjoy it too.

L to R : Ashwin Gandhi, Sonali Malvankar, Sandeep Godbole and Ajey Godbole

This writeup lists the temples from the list of temples available from the Peshwa period that we have been able to identify and visited as part of the tour.

  1. Kasba Ganpati : This temple undoubtedly is the most important temple in Pune. As the Gram Daivat or Village Deity of the city, it receives prominent position in the social, religious and cultural lives of the city and its citizens. Located behind the Lal Mahal, it is believed that the temple was resurrected by Jijabai, the mother of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj. The Deity is not a man made Murti but a natural ‘tandala’ or a form found in the natural form. The temple has a timber Sabhamandap and the main temple built in stone. Shri Kasba Ganpati Temple – Google Maps
  1. Parvati Nandan Ganpati : The Deity is also referred to as the temple at the Ganesh Khind or the hill pass. The temple was restored a few years ago by a team of restoration architects and local citizens. https://goo.gl/maps/7CTcW7yE3438ef4U9
  • Ganpati at the Chatushringi Temple : The Deity is Located at the Chatushringi Temple. On the way up to the Chatushringi temple it is located to the left along the steps that lead to the top. https://goo.gl/maps/hHN3QuFU6SmbbMvr8

3. Dashabhuja Ganpati : The Dashabhuja Ganpati is located on Karve Road. The Deity is not mentioned in any of the Peshwa Era lists. However it is said that the Deity was installed by Haripant Phadke. It is possible that being far away beyond the village of Erandwane it may not have been considered as a Deity in the city then. https://goo.gl/maps/ctAsEJNy1nWdDnbD9

4. Phadke Ganpati at Sinhagad Road : The temple is nestled at the foot of the hills that run parallel to the Sinhagad Road opposite the Rajaram Bridge. The location in historical records is referred to as the temple at Ganeshkhind ( this is different than the Ganeshkhind near the University). https://goo.gl/maps/hj9cLLda2CTwsyDQ8

5. Wadacha Ganpati: Wad in Marathi means the Banyan tree. The temple is next to a large banyan tree giving it the name. The temple was also referred to as the Phule Ganpati. The cornerstone of the existing temple refers to it being built in 1970 ! The reason for including it in the Heritage Ganpati list is that the Murti appears to be from an earlier era. Further some people do believe it to be old, though we need to examine whether evidence to the effect does exist. https://goo.gl/maps/kXuaHGnwRVFPRc5eA

6. Sarasbaug Ganpati: The Ganpati Temple at the Sarasbaug was built during the reign of Sawai Madhavrao Peshwa in 17XX. It was then on an island in the middle of the Parvati lake. The temple was renovated and expanded later in the mid 1970s. https://goo.gl/maps/3gdD4g8Cwu8f8fb46

7. Ganpati at Navloba/Narmadeshwar Temple: Navloba is considered to be the village Deity of the Parvati Village. The Murti is unique in its way. Unlike most Ganesh Murti that are seen, this Deity is standing upright. There is mention of a Ganpati in what was then Parvati Village. However whether this was the same cannot be ascertained with certainty. That the Deity is about a 100 year old atleast can however definitely by said from published information available. https://goo.gl/maps/WpnRmQAten7rWa4n7

8. Ramana Ganpati : At the foothills of Parvati is the Ramana Ganpati Temple. The Deity was earlier on an open platform there. The Ramana was an enclosure created by the Peshwas to hold congregation of the learned scholars. The congregation was held to test their scholarship and grant them a dakshina in line with their scholastic abilities. The temple for the Deity was built later by the Dev-Deveshwar Sansthan. Https://goo.gl/maps/JCTQWQT214P7GeY87

9. Ganpati at Parvati Dev-Deveshwar Sansthan: Nanashaeb Peshwa considered as the architect of Pune built the Dev-Deveshwar Temple. This temple atop the Parvati Hill is one of the most iconic temples. At four corners of the courtyard of the temple are small temples or shrines dedicated to different Deities- Ganpati, Vishnu, Suryanarayan, Devi (Bhawani), Parvati. Historical records also refer to the Ganesh in the Sadar or veranda. Photos of these Deities are not available since photography of the Deities is not permitted at this complex. https://goo.gl/maps/xNETB6VfDGHQdGDRA

10. Ganpati at the Bhikardas Maruti: The Bhikardas Maruti is one of the more popular Maruti Mandirs in Pune. The Deities were located in the garden of one Bhikaridas, a rich businessman during the Peshwa days. The Ganpati is in the same temple and placed adjacent to the Maruti. https://goo.gl/maps/q1mVvak3g9QvTpB98

11. Ganpati at the Narsimha Mandir: The Narsimha Mandir is from the later decades of the 1700s. The Ganpati is placed in the Sabha-Mandap of the Laxmi Narsimha Temple. One of the earliest revolutionaries in the country -Vasudev Balwant Phadke resided in the precincts of this temple. https://goo.gl/maps/R7MMwRtGh6d6C2F99

12. Junya Jaicha Ganpati: The history of this temple is not known to us. It appears to be one of the Ganpati mentioned in the Peshwa List. We cannot however state with complete certainty. The Deity is located in a building on the ground floor at Shukrawar Peth and is near Raja Kelkar Museum. https://goo.gl/maps/R7MMwRtGh6d6C2F99

13. Chimnya Ganpati: The Deity was earlier placed on a platform. As per locals, the offering to the Deity attracted sparrows who used to flock there giving it the name. Chimni in Marathi means sparrow. How is it cannot be said with certainty, however it is likely to be one of the temples mentioned in Sadashiv Peth as per the Peshwa list. https://goo.gl/maps/Gg2VsyGRL3V3nxRj9

14. Ganpati at Johari Mahadev: The temple is hidden in the midst of modern buildings at Sadashiv Peth. The main Deity is Mahadev. The temple has Murti of Parvati behind Shivalinga. The temple also has Murti of Virbhadra and Ganpati.https://goo.gl/maps/vGqbgsSqc8ACZXSS7

15. Maaticha Ganpati: Maati means soil or earth. Since the Deity was cast from earth this Deity got its name. The Murti is large in size. This is one of the more important temples in earlier times since it is mentioned in all the three Peshwa lists. https://goo.gl/maps/e2PqQfoM5e4Cc32s7

16. Modi Ganpati: The Modi Ganpati get its name since near it once stood a garden that belonged to Khrushet Modi. The teample has a traditional look with the shikhar and sloping roof. https://goo.gl/maps/vmdog747TGjU2bSk7

17. Pawaskar Ganpati: We are unaware of the exact year when the Ganpati was established, however likely to be in the later 1700s. The Ganpati is not mentioned in the Peshwa list. The head of the Joshi Pawaskar family is said to have accurately predicted the birth of Sawai Madhavrao when the Maratha power was in turmoil and desperately seeking a male heir. The traditional Murti was earlier housed in a temple inside the wada or old house. A few decades ago when the property was rebuilt this new temple for the Deity was constructed at the location. https://goo.gl/maps/ZNUZYhW1HTGCJENT6

18. Ganpati at Harihareshwar Temple: This Ganpati is located at the Harihareshwar Shiva Temple. The Ganpati is adorned with semi-precios stone and placed in the sabhamandap of this temple. Harihareshwar being the family Deity of the Peshwas, it is likely that the temple may have received patronage from the the Peshwas. The location as per the link is not fully accurate, the temple is a 100 meters away from this location https://goo.gl/maps/HAzbKr1asisnhAA2A

19. Ganpati at the Amruteshwar Temple: The Amruteshwar Temple near the Shaniwar Wada is likely to have been built around the mid-1750s.The temple has a beautiful shikar that is tall, however the Sabhamandap is quite small. The appearance of this Ganpati is a bit different. The Ganpati is located outside the Gabhara at the Sabhamandap. https://goo.gl/maps/NLKCsmYRAUs5vNan6

20. Ganpati at Siddheshwar: This Siddheshwar temple is located at the Amruteshwar Temple complex. This Ganpati is quite unique and is located in the square sabha-mandap of this temple. https://goo.gl/maps/NLKCsmYRAUs5vNan6

21. Ganpati at at the Ashtabhuja (Nava Durga) Temple: The temple located at Narayan Peth near the river finds mention in the Peshwa list. https://goo.gl/maps/Z65ks5tU3NZ7Rz6q7

22. Ganpati at the Omkareshwar Temple: The Omkareshwar Temple was built around 1736 by Chimajiappa, the younger brother of Bajirao-I. The temple is well maintained and the main Deity is the Omkareshwar – Mahadev. Outside the Gabhara or the Garbhagriha is an old Murti of Ganesh with distinctive features. https://goo.gl/maps/My7N1EGs1BkkWHo96

23. Ganpati at Vruddheshwar Temple: The Vruddheshwar was an important temple of what was the Bhambawde Village during Peshwa period. The temple is situated at the Mutha river. In the Garbhagriha of the temple is located a this Ganesh Murti. https://goo.gl/maps/1AJsYCQAPp3M4hfe6

24. Ganpati at Nilkantheshwar: The Nilkantheshwar is a small temple and possibly a temple from the early Peshwa period. This small temple located near the Mujumdar Wada also has a Ganpati Murti. https://goo.gl/maps/bK7ZNUUcZ1W33SWg6

25. Peshwa Ganpati: The Peshwa Ganpati is located at the Ganesh Darwaja of the Shaniwar Wada. Earlier records refer it to the Ganpati at the Ganesh Darwaja of the ‘sarkar wada – juna wada’. https://goo.gl/maps/kN9TLdvNvkQ94bdu6

26. Ganpati at the Kedareshwar Temple: The Kedareshwar is one of the oldest temples in Pune. Though the present temple structure is from the 1730-40 period, the Deities are believed to be over 700 years old. There are two Ganesh Deities, one located in the Sabhamandap and the other in the courtyard outside, behind the other Shiving located outside. https://goo.gl/maps/NULyPzomn4XFnHQ36

27. Phadke Wada Ganpati: Sardar Haripant Phadke was a prominent nobleman and army general during the times of Madhavrao and Sawai Madhavrao Peshwa. The temple was located in his huge mansion or wada. After reconstruction of the mansion, the old temple is in the premises of the apartment. https://goo.gl/maps/pTf1uHq8M8NLVeHi7

28. Gundacha Ganpati: The name of the Deity is derived probably from the name of one ‘Nagoji Gund’ whose house was then nearby. The Murti of the Deity was replaced a few decades ago. The old Murti is placed on the circumbulation or ‘pradakshina’ path in side the temple. https://goo.gl/maps/86J1UxJ2epJNWHHs6

29. Ganpati at the Phadke Mahadev Temple: The Temple has been referred to as the Rameshwar Temple in the historical records. This is yet one more temple associated with Sardar Haripant Phadke. The Deity is located in the Sabhamandap outside the Garbhagriha. https://goo.gl/maps/oA3o91x4rWcfL52A9

30. Ganpati at the Nageshwar Temple: The Nageshwar temple is one of the oldest Mahadev temples in the city. The older part of the temple is the Garbhagriha and the stone mandap while the newer parts are the timber Sabhamandap. The older potions or parts of it are believed to be from the late Yadava period and the Sabhamandap is from the Peshwa period. In the Garbhagriha of the Nageshwar is a very unique Murti of Ganpati. https://goo.gl/maps/1vR7fetd2muqzWzE7

31. Ganpati near Trishunda Temple: This Ganpati is between the Nageshwar and Trishunda Ganpati Temples. The Deity has been referred to the ‘Ganpati in the devli near Dadambhat Vateshwar house’ in the Peshwa list. https://goo.gl/maps/ZxhnrKawAttQCVsU9

32. Trishunda Ganpati: The temple is one of the most ornate temples in Pune. It was built in the 1760s by Bhimgiriraj Gosavi. The Deity is quite unique in that it has ‘tri-shund’ or three trunks. https://goo.gl/maps/UEc9fQWNFSybPW2s5

33. Ganpati at the Laxmeshwar/Laxmaneshwar: The temple was built by the Rate family, probably by Anadrao Raste from the family. The presiding Deity at the temple is Mahadev. The Ganpati is in the Sabhamandap. https://goo.gl/maps/PKZQBUHszwVxymz39

34. Ganpati near Dulya Maruti towards Nagjhari: There is a mention in the Peshwa list of the Ganpati on the banks of the Nagjhari stream, behind Dulya Hanumant. The temple location matches this description. Deity is located in a small temple opposite the Kal-Bhairav Temple next to the the old Alpana Talkies building. https://goo.gl/maps/5MDmpn7AJNrGEL1u5

35. Ganpati Adjacent to the Dulya Maruti: As mentioned in the Peshwa list, the temple is adjacent to the Dulya Maruti temple and to it’s north. https://goo.gl/maps/v4yHNo8ZXq474V1M8

36. Ganpati at the Someshwar Temple: The Someshwar temple complex at Raviwar Peth has many temples in addition to the presiding Deity – Someshwar. The Ganpati is established in its own shrine just next to the main Someshwar Sabhamandap. https://goo.gl/maps/xdHjLsRhC8hKvQoF7

37. Ganpati at the Kali Jogeshwari: There are three well known Jogeshwari temples in Pune – The Tambdi, Kali and Pivli Jogeshwari. The Ganpati at the Kali Jogeshwari Temple is at the opposite end of the temple facing the Murti of Kali Jogeshwari. https://goo.gl/maps/RgWJAqvSmTxR8vm5A

38. Ganpati at the Rameshwar Temple: The Rameshwar Temple was built by the Khasgiwale (Limaye) family in the mid 18th Century. The Ganpati is located in the Sabhamandap of the temple. https://goo.gl/maps/Ji5GyTLXeDfQkupa7

39. Tulshibaug: The Tulshibaug Temple Complex is probably the biggest Heritage Temple Complex in the city. There are temples dedicated to various Deities in the complex. The main temple is that of Sri Ram. There is a temple dedicated to Ganpati too in the Tulshibaug Complex. https://goo.gl/maps/z5aat3jZYfkBq8Wb

40. Ganpati to the north of Tulshibaug: This small Ganpati Temple was described in old records ar located to the south of Naro Shivram Chakradeo wada. At present the temple is behind the huge Murti of the Sarvajani Ganeshotsav. https://goo.gl/maps/PRBebNiSkUJJqPYv7

41. Ganpati in the Mahadev temple Near Ganpati Chowk: This Mahadev Temple is said to have been built in memory of Ramabai Peshwe the wife of Madhavrao. Ramabai committed ‘sati’ when Madhavrao died. This quaint temple has two Murtis of Ganpati https://goo.gl/maps/qNhKx2vK5hWoN8j97

42. Ganpati at Laxmi Road: Located at the Ganpati Chowk, this Ganpati temple was once located in the middle of the road from where it was shifted to the side. The Guruji Talim Sarvajanik Ganeshotsav is held near this temple. In historical records it is referred to as the Ganpati in the middle of the reoad near the Chopdar House. https://goo.gl/maps/7qrgWWgp8vw3z87M9

43. Ganpati at Tambdi Jogeshwari: The Tambdi Jogeshwari Deity has the privilege as the ‘Gram Devtaa’ of Pune. At four corners of the temple courtyard are four small temples. One of the temple is dedicated to Ganpati. https://goo.gl/maps/7qrgWWgp8vw3z87M9

44. Ganpati at Vitthal Mandir at Phadgate: The Vitthal Mandir opposite the Phadgate Police Chowky has Deities in addition to Vitthal also. One of the Deities there is Ganpati. https://goo.gl/maps/6ruNPEg1vbY8egmp6

We have compiled this list for the benefit of citizens who want to visit Heritage Temples and Deities. Visiting all the Deities mentioned in this list is possible over a period of one week on cycle by riding about 1.5 hours on each of the days. We have shared Google Map locations to easily locate the Deities. Happy Exploring !

Dr Vasantrao Deshpande – Reminiscences of an associate-friend

Vasantrao Deshpande was a much loved singer and actor. He enthralled music lovers accross the country by his unique and distinctive style. His versatility in singing different genres of Indian classical and semi-classical music remains unmatched. He sang bandish, natyageet, thumri, Marathi Bhavgeet with ease and elan. He was a recipient of the Sangeet Natak Academy Award.

G. T. Godbole, a successful lawyer, was person of multiple talents. He was an artist, poet, orator with command over English and Marathi, singer, musician and a student of Marathi and Kannada Saint-Poet literature. This article, written by him on the occasion of Vasantrao Deshpande’s first death anniversary on 30th July 1984. The article was printed in the newspaper ‘Sandhya’ published from Pune.

The article was shared by courtesy of Kaustubh Ponkshe who had it in his collection.

Dhondumama Sathe : A Man In Hurry

Pune is the favourite city of not just its inhabitants but of others who aspire to make it their home. What is it that makes some of the cities around the world to be favoured destination. Is it the climate, the geography or the resources, or something else. While hygiene factors are certainly important, of  greater significance is the support provided by the city in nurturing the spirit of enterprise, the support extended for creativity of citizens and the development of institutions of repute by its citizens.

The city of Pune has achieved its status due to its many talented and hard working citizens with a spectacular vision who toiled to built reputed institutions. Dhondo Krishna Sathe, popularly known as Dhondumama Sathe was one such worthy son of Pune.  Long before the term became popular, he was one of the first serial entrepreneur from Pune.  He was born on 1st Sep 1891 in a prosperous family at Pune. The family were steel merchants and civil construction contractors. After completing his BA and BSc degrees from Pune, Dhondumama travelled to England to study for the ICS examination. Fate had something else in store and he had to return back to Pune due to the untimely demise of his elder brother. Dhondumama thus had to abandon the ICS exam take charge of his family business. Even for a prosperous family from Pune aiming for the ICS exam was a big dream. This trait stuck throughout Dhondumama’s life who always aimed big and worked with utmost devotion to realise the dreams.

While in England he dressed like a European gentleman, in India his attire was simple – dhoti, shirt, coat, turban or traditional black cap popularly worn in Maharashtra. On his return from England, he accompanied Lokmanya Tilak on his tours during 1916-17 that further kindled the patriotic spark. Throughout his own life Dhondumama was loyal follower of Lokmanya Tilak. After Lokmanya’s demise, Dhodumama had very close association with N C alias Tatyasaheb Kelkar who was carried Tilak’s legacy further. It was Lokmanya’s influence that saw Dhondumama participate in public activities and various agitations and satyagraha. He was also influenced by Acharya Vinoba Bhave briefly. He participated in the ‘Bhoodan Movement’ led by Vinoba Bhave for some time. In 1950 Savarkar was lodged at the Hindalga Jail, Belgaum by the government. A habeas corpus was filed in the High Court at Mumbai against this long detention. Dhondumama assumed responsibility for the court expenses related to this case. He also went along with leaders from Pune to welcome Savarkar on his release from jail.

Dhondumama created a name for himself as a building contractor. Some of the notable landmarks that he constructed include the SP College at Pune, The Pune Railway Station Building, Ruia College, Mumbai, New English School Pune, Aryan Education Society at Girgaon, Mumbai. The artistic canopy of Lokmanya Tiak’s status at Mahatma Phule Mandai in Pune was built by him. He was also instrumental in getting the former Headquarters of the Bank of Maharashtra on Bajirao Road, Pune constructed.

In 1930 the noted economist Dhanajayrao Gadgil spearheaded the formation of the District Central Co-Op Bank ( now the Pune District Central Co-Op Bank – PDCC). Dhondumama was associated with this venture. From 1932-36 he served as the Director of the Bank and from 1937-40 he served as the Chairman. He was convinced that availability of banking services and availability of capital was key to the growth of commerce. Though he was associated with the bank he believe that a private banking venture would provide greater flexibility and dynamism. It was here that the thoughts about setting up a new private bank were seeded.

Dhondumama performing Bhoomi Pujan of Bank of Maharashtra Building – 1949

Inauguration – Bank of Maharashtra – 1936 Dhondumama – 4th from right

Dhondumama took sincere efforts to establish a new private bank – Bank of Maharashtra that was set up in 1935. He approached friends and business contacts and raised capital for the bank. His colleagues requested him to be the chairman of the bank. Dhondumama however refused and suggested that Prof Kale by the virtue of being an economist was better suited and qualified to take the responsibility of the new venture. Prof Kale finally accepted the responsibility with some persuasion. Later Dhondumama took up the responsibility as the Chairman from 1943 to 1953. Dhondumama was a simple person and as a customer of the bank always denied any special treatment that was offered. At times bank tellers used to be taken aback to see Dhondumama wait in a queue for getting his transactions serviced. He used to refuse any special courtesy offered to him as the chief promoter and board member of the bank.

Along with A R Bhat, Dhondumama played a major role in the formation of the Mahratta Chamber of Commerce ( now MCCIA). He was a trustee of the new organization in the initial years. Today the MCCIA is a premier organization that represents the industries and entrepreneurs in the Pune region.

With Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee, first Industries Minister, Dhondumama – first from right

Dhondumama was very passionate about industry and commerce and was convinced of its positive role in the development of the country. Trained people were the bedrock for any meaningful progress. Those days there was a solitary engineering college in Pune offering degree in engineering. This catered to the erstwhile Bombay state that also included parts of Gujarat and North Karnataka. Dhondumama was consumed by a new passion of setting up an engineering college to provide skilled experts who would contribute in the industrial development. He worked hard to achieve the dream and set up the Maharashtra Technical Education Society. The plan was to start the college in Pune. However at the request of B G Kher it was decided to establish it elsewhere since Pune already had an engineering college. The Rajesaheb of Sangli and the Walchand Group supported his efforts and the college was established in Sangli. The New Engineering College was established in 1947. The college was renamed Walchand College of Engineering in 1955. The then Vice President Dr S Radhakrishnan graced this function the chief guest.

Dr S Radhakrishnan, then Vice President of India, Dhondumama 2nd from right, Walchand College, Sangli 1955

Establishing a Homeopathic Medical College was another dream that he pursued with dedication. Homeopathy offers affordable treatment and hence suitable for our country was his belief. With his friends and colleagues he set up on this task and remained the main driving force. The Homeopathy College was established in 1969 at the SP College Campus. Within a few years the college moved to its own premises near Karve Road at Pune. The college was given his name by the society after his death. The Sanjeevan Hospital attached to the College is one of the important hospitals serving patients in Pune city today.

In some ways Dondumama was a maverick. At the height of his success he roamed for almost a year as an ascetic – a sanyasi across the north of India from the Himalayan foothills to the plains of the Punjab. On his return he decided that his ‘sanyaas’ would be different. He would continue his activities with passion but with complete detachment. He was associated with many social organizations including Sarvajanik Sabha, Ved Shastrottejak Sabha, Shikshan Prasarak Mandali, Pune Municipality, Ayurved Rasa Shala, Paisa Fund Glass Factory at Talegaon and many more. His wife Umabai remained his support always. They did not have an heir but both Umabai and Dhondumama never expressed any disappointment. Umabai as a the lady of the house was always welcoming to everyone irrespective of the social status or contribution. The couple were great believers in the importance of ‘Anna Daana’ or offering food to those who need or desire. Their kitchen at home used to feed thousands of guests, relatives, friends or simply those who needed support each year. All visitors around lunch time or dinner time were invited to stay on and have food with them.

As a freedom fighter, Dhondumama participated in the Hyderabad Liberation Movement. He was imprisioned by the Nizam. He faced a brutal and inhuman lathi attack by the Nizams forces when in jail. For eight days after the brutal assault, he was even unable to move. He suffered serious injuries on his back and limbs. Over time some of the injuries healed, however his fingers remained impacted for the rest of his life.

He supported a large number of students to complete their education by providing assistance in cash or kind. Dhondumama’s wide social circle was also part of his endevaours. N C Kelkar, Datto Waman Potdar, F D Pudumjee, Chandrashekhar Agashe, N G Pawar, N V Gadgil, A R Bhat and other prominent citizens were his associates in many of the ventures.

Dhondumama lived his life to the full. As an entrepreneur and as a businessman he was successful in many ventures, but also took failure in his stride. He was an ardent devotee of Ganpati but devotion to God not make him lazy or inert. He believed in the importance of hard work and efforts to achieve success. He was motivated to undertake novel ideas. One such idea was a funicular system to transport trucks over the Nane Ghat near Junnar from Mumbai region to the Maharashtra Plateau. He established a private company for this project. The concept however was too advanced for its time and did not progress further.

He remained a true Karma Yogi, forever motivated to take up work and activity. He generally shied away from publicity. He took both success and failures in his stride, more importantly he never remained attached to either the creation nor the results. Dhondumama can be best described as a ‘person in hurry’, for he always had a lot that he wanted to do. He had the strength of character to give up and move on from a successful activity without attempting to hold on to the glory. Dhondumama Sathe breathed his last on 17 Sept 1975, it seems a long time ago, but his approach to life continues to be as refreshing as ever. As a businessman, social entrepreneur, freedom fighter, spiritualist his activities transgressed multiple areas. It is people like him to whom the city owes its position and the institutions that they helped to build. As grateful citizens, we can cherish their contribution.

The Parsis Of Pune

Our Pune city holds in its embrace a relatively large population of the Parsi Community. Parsis are largely concentrated in the western parts of India – Mumbai, Pune and parts of Gujarat. Pune city has been enriched by the contribution of the Parsi community.

The 2011 census puts the number of Parsis in India at approximately sixty thousand. Thus, it is likely that the population of the community in Pune could be in the range of about six to seven thousand. For a numerically small community, their contributions have been quite significant. Of the Parsi Agiaris or the Parsi Fire Temples in the city, the Sardar Sorabji Ratanji Patel Dar e Meher Agiary, the oldest, was established in 1843 at Rasta Peth. This is a possible indication that the population of the Parsis in Pune may have increased after the second decade of the nineteenth century, after the British defeated the Marathas and established complete control over Pune.

Pg_06-Pune-Dar-e-Meherr

Pune is known for its many quirks including unconventional names for its many temples. One the Ganpati Temples has a Parsi name. At Narayan Peth, a stone throw away from Laxmi Road is the ‘Modi’ Ganpati. It is believed that the ‘murti’ was discovered in a garden owned by Khushrushet Modi. This is possibly the only instance of a Hindu Temple named after a Parsi, anywhere in the whole world. The temple was constructed in the the first half of the nineteenth century, this means that Parsis may have made Pune their home by then.

ModiGanpati

Around 1850 Sir Jamsetjee Jeejeebhoy, a wealthy Parsi businessman contributed generously to the construction of a bund at Pune. The bund or small dam created a reservoir in the waters of the Mula-Mutha river. The place was scenic and at the height of the colonial rule the area near the bund was developed into the ‘Bund Garden’ frequented regularly by the Britishers.

Bund1870, Royal Collection

The Bund  1870 from Royal Collection Trust / © Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II 2020

Principle N D Nagarvala ‘Noss’, was from the city of Ahmednagar near Pune. Later he studied at the Deccan College and Fergusson College and made Pune his home. He was a good sportsman. Representing Maharashtra in the Ranji Trophy, he held the world record along with Vijay Hajare for a 256 run partnership for the ninth wicket. Besides a sportsman, he was a staunch nationalist and teacher at heart. He founded the National Model School (now renamed as Erin N Nagarvala School) and personally dedicated himself to the school. The school due to his commitment, etched its name as a school that promoted the all round development of students.

Though not a Punekar, a much loved Parsi by the city was Pandit Firoz Dastur. Each year he was accorded the honour of performing at the Sawai Gandharva Music Festival at Pune. Without fail the audience used to lovingly demand that he perform the bhajan ‘Gopala meri karuna kyon nahi’, and he always honoured the request. This masterpiece was sung by Ustad Abdul Karim Khan and passed on through his disciple Sawai Gandharva to Pandit Dastur.

There are many institutions in Pune that were promoted by members of the Parsi community. Dr Grant’s contribution to setting up the ‘Ruby Hall’ is illustrious. The city recognized his long service and he was also the recipient of the ‘Punya Bhushan Award’. Dr Banoo Koyaji’s contribution to the development of the KEM hospital has been inspiring. Her effort proved beneficial to the thousands of patients who have who have been treated by the hospital. She also served on the Board of Sakal Newspaper for many years. Dr Koyaji and Dr Grant, these are but two names from the medical field, among many more, where the Parsis have served our city.

Fishers Gym was one of the pioneering ‘no-nonsense’ brawny gyms in Pune established by Bejan Fishers. This was long before work outs at upmarket and air conditioned gyms became fashionable. In many ways the gym can be considered a pioneer in Pune. The gym saw many enthusiasts challenge their own selves and achieve their passion and potential for fitness.

Many commercial establishments that are identified with Pune were established by Parsi entrepreneurs. The Thermax Group was the brainchild and hard work of Rohington Aga and family. The Serum Institute owned by the Poonawala family is another example of the pioneering spirit among the Parsis. The Kayani Bakery has been a favorite in Pune for their cakes and biscuits for years. The Dorabjee Restaurant faithfully dishes out Parsi favorites to their clients for years. Penosh Transport has transported thousands of travelers on daily commute to offices and excursions. Marz O Rin has been a regular haunt for many in Pune. Dorabjee’s Store has catered to the customers needs in groceries, spirits and more for over a hundred years.

kayani-bakery-759

There is so much more that has been contributed by the Parsi community in and from Pune. The community has blended itself without compromising it’s identity. The community has enriched our city in a multitude of vibrant ways !

Nanasaheb Peshwa : Architect of Modern Pune

It was on this day 23 June in the year 1761 that Balaji Bajirao Peshwa, known as Nanasaheb breathed his last in his ‘wada’ or residence atop the Parvati Hill. Those who are connected to Pune owe a lot to Nanasaheb, for it was his vision and efforts that developed Pune in multiple ways. Infrastructure development and beautification of the city received a boost during his reign. It was due to this that Pune was able to attract and retain talent in the city.

Peshwa_Balaji_Bajirao

Peshwa Balaji Bajirao alias Nanasaheb

Nanasaheb was born on 8 December 1720 to illustrious father Bajirao-I and mother Kashibai. The whirlwind lifestyle of Bajirao-I meant that he was generally away from the family at Pune most of the time. Thus it is likely that Nanasaheb must have been drawn to support the administration quite early in life preparing him for the time to come. Bajirao-I died in 1740, and the 19 year old was appointed the successor, as the next Peshwa by Chhatrapati Shahu Maharaj. Nanasaheb, like his father was bestowed the robes of this office at quite a young age. However, beyond this similarity there were also some differences. Bajirao-I ‘s temperament was that of a soldier and a general. Due to the political situation of the times he spent his life in military expeditions protecting and expanding the Maratha Empire. By the time Nanasaheb assumed office, the Maratha Empire had stabilised to a large extent and had became a power to recon with. The Empire had reached Attock ( now Pakistan ) in the north and was at its zenith during Nanasaheb’s reign. The Maratha Empire got an able Prime Minister in the form of Nanasaheb in the truest sense who was able to provide attention to aspects beyond the military imperatives. This he did and Pune developed due to his vision.

One of the landmark infrastructure development projects initiated and completed by Nanasaheb within a very short time was the restructuring the path of the Ambil Odha. Nagzari and Ambil Odha are the two main water streams that feed the Mutha River in Pune. The Ambil Odha originates in the Katraj Hills about 5 miles away from the Shaniwar Wada and joined the Mutha just a stone throw away to the west of the Shaniwar Wada. Explained in terms of today’s landmarks, it flowed all the way from Katraj to Parvati, from there approximately along the Bajirao Road, Bhau Maharaj Bol, further down, adjecent to the Jogeshwari Temple and ultimately joined the Mutha near the Amruteshwar Temple. Ambil Odha caused flooding during monsoon resulting at times into loss of human life. Besides, it restricted the contours of growth of the city that was becoming increasingly populous. Nanasaheb altered the flow of the Ambil Odha in 1755 and redirected the flow to outside the city, to where it meets the Mutha near the Mhatre Bridge of the day. As part of this activity he built a bund to alter the flow and excavated a lake to store the excess water from Ambil Odha. The lake was meant to create a reserve source of water in case of emergencies or if other water sources became unavailable. The lake was completed around 1755 in only two years. This excavated lake is the Saras Baug Garden as we know it today. In the middle of the lake he developed a small garden that could only be reached by boat. The Ganpati temple was established on the same island after his reign. Nanasaheb also developed Hira Baug on the banks of the lake and a built a resort there. The structure since the 1870’s became the Town Hall where multiple social, cultural and sports activites were organised.

Another landmark development during Nanasaheb’s time was the development of the water supply scheme for the city. Till the 1730’s Pune was a relatively small place. The Mutha, along with Ambil Odha and Nagzari were the main sources of water. Besides, there were wells that provided water to the residents. As Pune became the seat of power not just of the Maratha Empire but an important power centre for the entire country, there was an influx of people and the population of the city rose steadily. The three water streams were found inadequate especially during the summer months. Water is essential for any development and so Nanasaheb embarked in 1749 on an ambitious plan to supply water to the city. He constructed two lakes at Katraj, that is a water catchment area due to the hilly terrain. There was an upper lake and a lower lake in the scheme; water was directed from the upper lake to the lower lake. The upper lake served to settle the sediments in the water. From here, water was transported to Pune about five miles away using underground water pipes. The pipes were carved out of stone. Later other water supply systems during the Peshwa times used terracotta pipes in place of stone pipes. The water from Katraj through a natural filtration process reached the city. Multiple water tanks or houds were built along the flow of this water pipeline for people to draw water. Kala Houd, Badami Houd, Houd in Bhau Maharaj Bol, Tulshi Baug Houd, Nana Wada Houd were just some of them. There were over 50 such houds that were built to supply water. Few of them still exist however due to the contamination of ground water in the recent years, its use has dwindled. I have myself seen and experienced the clear and cool water as late as the early1990s. A benefit of this scheme often overlooked is its contribution in maintaining a high water table in the central parts of Pune City. To this day most wells in this part of the city have plenty of water all round the year.

Nanasaheb_Parvati

His last resting place at Parvati; photo ack – Amit Paranjape

Nanasaheb beautified the Parvati Hill in 1749 where a small temple of Parvati – probably Parvat-aai existed from the earlier times. He built a bigger temple for the Goddess, besides he also established the Devdeveshwar, Parvati, Vishnu Ganpati and Surya temples. Nanasaheb also built a wada or residence on the hill. It is here that he breathed his last, forlorn after the humungous loss at the Battle of Panipat, including the death of his son Vishwasrao and his dear cousin Sadashivrao Bhau on the battlefield. The place where Nanasaheb died at Parvati is open to visitors who want to pay their respects.

It was during Nanasaheb’s time that Pune expanded rapidly. He encouraged artisans, traders and other to settle in the city. He expanded the existing Peths to provide for their stay and vocation. The Shaniwar wada was fortified with surrounding wall. The walled structure and imposing entrance to the Shaniwar Wada that we see today was built during his time. The efforts of Nanasaheb elevated Pune to the status befitting its position as the seat of power during the era. His contribution as the architect of modern Pune is not known to many. As a society we have done little to acknowledge his contribution. His Samadhi at the Mutha river bed is the only visible signature erected by the government that we have to show, for our gratitude to the person who enriched our beloved city.

MuthaNanasahebSamadhi

Nanasaheb’s Samadhi at the Mutha riverbed.

 

Gopal Krishna Gokhale : The Democrat

GKGokhale

Gopal Krishna Gokhale was born on 9th May 1866 in a small village named Kotluk near Chiplun, in the District of Ratnagiri, in the state of Maharashtra of today. After the early demise of his father his elder brother Govind Krishna Gokhale took charge of the family and of young Gopal. Govind took a job as a police officer in the state of Kagal near Kolhapur and encouraged and supported Gopal in his education and Gopal did not disappoint him. Young Gopal did his primary schooling at Kagal.

Thereafter he enrolled at the Rajaram College at Kolhapur and then at the Elphinstone College. Gokhale was an exceptionally bright student, completed his matriculation two year ahead of his contemporaries and became a graduate at the young age of 18.  Thereafter he joined the New English School at Pune as a teacher, drawn by the idealism of its founders that included Tilak and Agarkar. It was here that he first met Tilak whom he had admired. His views gradually matured and he was drawn by the thoughts of Agarkar who introduced him to Mahadev Govind Ranade. Gokhale’s views on economic, social and political reforms were greatly conditioned by Ranade in these formative years. He believed in the interplay of these reforms and was convinced that the different reforms need to go together, hand in hand. Ranade who played the role of a mentor and Gokhale was soon one of his brightest followers.

One of the significant works of Gokhale was his presentation to the Wellby commission. The Commission was set up to study the expenditures made by the Indian Government. Gokhale’s deep study of economics was always supported by facts and quantification. He articulated that the British government was leaving a burden of 20 crores per year on the Indian masses. In 1897, this was a very huge amount. He argued that the government and administration in India was not controlled by any constitutional arrangement. That the officials were through  the Viceroy and Secretary of State for India responsible to the British Parliament. However in this entire arrangement there was no accountability towards the Indian  people. Nobody thus seemed answerable to the Indian population.

Gokhale had joined Fergusson College as a Professor of Mathematics at the age of 20 ! Gokhale took a lot of efforts for the Deccan Education Society and the Fergusson College. He not only taught at the college but also used his contacts to generate funds for the institution. The impressive buildings that stand proudly today, even after so many years, owe a bit of gratitude to Gokhale. After the death of Ranade in 1901, Gokhale  became the leader of the moderate faction of the nationalists. In 1898 he was elected to the Bombay Legislative Council and later to the Imperial Council of the Governor General in 1902. It was then that he decided to devote himself completely to public life and resigned from his responsibilities at the Fergusson College.

Gokhale’s speeches on the budget were very scholarly, based on facts and linked to the realities of our motherland. His presentation was fearless and flawless. Gokhale therefore  never had to fall back on slander, abuse or disrespect when countering opposing views or debating with his adversaries.

He opposed the Official Secrets Act forcefully in the council in 1902 and showed the mirror to the British officials governing India. He declared that the law that cannot be enforced in Britain, for it will be opposed tooth and nail in Britain, is being foisted upon India. He pointed out that the beneficial practices and governance adopted in  Britain were not followed in India. In fact, in India the governance and laws are exactly opposite and repressive. The British Government was always on the tenterhooks when Gokhale rose to speak. Gokhale never made loose statements and did not speak without evidence. Despite this, he was respected by the government, for he was fearless, pure, cultured and a true gentleman, in all respects.

India was going through economic recession during 1902. Surprisingly, the government budget indicated a surplus of seven crores. Accumulation of surplus during recession defied economic logic. Gokhale strongly advocated an increase in spending by the government to heal the economy. He argued that the taxes were disproportionate to the poor country, which was the reason for the surplus. He argued that such practices were pushing India into greater poverty. His speeches were always meaningful with quantification and solution. He demanded greater government spending to provide free and compulsory education. It is now after about a hundred years since Gokhale first brought up the topic that we have the Right to Education Act.

Noted educationist Sarla Roy once confronted Gokhale with the question – You believe in equality and fraternity and you consider that everybody is equal in the eyes of God,  then why do you wear the sacred thread that is identified with Brahmins. Gokhale replied, I have not thought about this, I will definitely reflect and let you know. Gokhale knew the answer, he cut the thread and sent it to Sarla Ray by post. From that day, Gokhale never wore the sacred thread again.

Gokhale was a firm believer of service to the nation beyond the boundaries of caste and religions. He founded the Servants of India Society with the sole aim of service to the nation. Members of the society were provided a stipend and forbidden to amass wealth for their own selves. The Servants of India Society was probably the first social organization in India not based on a religious or community affiliation.

This structure atop the Fergusson College Hill commemorates the pledge of the founders of the Servants of India Society.

This structure atop the Fergusson College Hill commemorates the pledge taken by the founders of the Servants Of India Society.

In 1905 Gokhale became President of the Congress at the Benaras Session. There he opposed Bengal Partition based on religious grounds. He always looked at the country beyond these narrow religious divisions. Gokhale also had a key role to play in the Morley Minto Reforms. This was the first attempt where Indian obtained rights under the British Government. This included elected representation to the provincial council. In fact some people opine that the reforms should actually have been referred as the Morley-Minto-Gokhale Reforms considering the contribution of Gopal Krishna Gokhale towards this initiative.

Though the practice of slavery had met its end, a similar sinister system existed in India. On 4th March 1912 Gokhale made a very genuine and passionate speech about this practice of Indentured Labour in the council. The system of indentured labour where workers from India were sent to British colonies outside India to work in sugarcane and other plantations was an inhuman practice. Gokhale was the first person to raise the issue about this inhuman practice. People were bound under contract to go overseas to places where they were complete strangers in all respects and work on the estates. They were bound to perform the tasks even when it seemed inhuman. They were bound to stay only on the estate and could not go elsewhere. Indentured labour in Fiji, Sri Lanka, Mauritius, S Africa, Guinea thus saw Gokhale as a hero and saviour. Gokhale asked the government in his speech as to why a practice that is not acceptable anywhere in the world be practiced in India and why should Indians suffer.

Gokhale therefore was an economist and a world leader. Probably the first person from India to achieve the status. He was heard keenly in Britain as a fine leader and and also where people of Indian origin were suffering from practices like indentured labour.  As an economist Gokhale went beyond the mere calculations and quantification. He was a humanist economist, connected to the ground who understood people and their suffering. He was one of the first leader to raise his voice against high tax on salt in British India. Salt being a basic necessity for all including the poor he opposed this tax. The same issue was picked up later by Mahatma Gandhi as part of the Dandi March.

In many respects Gokhale mentored and promoted Mahatma Gandhi. The two first met in 1896 when Gandhi was meeting Indian leaders regarding the struggles in South Africa. Later Gokhale also visited South Africa. On his return in India, he mentioned about Gandhi and the struggles in South Africa to the Indian people. He mentioned how ordinary people were transformed into fighters by Gandhi. At that time nobody knew Gandhi in India and everybody  knew Gokhale. In a way therefore, Gokhale used his personal credibility to introduce Gandhi to the Indians.

Gokhale was well aware of the need to connect and communicate. He travelled to many places in India. He also travelled many times to Britain and also to South Africa. His command over English was impeccable. With a view to spread the message, Gokhale started the Dnyan Prakash newspaper in Pune and the Hitvada in Nagpur.

Gokhale in a way is a gold standard in ethical politics. He was always polite in his language even with adversaries and opponents. He never doubted the intent of his adversaries or that of a contrary view. Gandhi openly recognised Gokhale as his guru. It is said that M A Jinnah aspired to be a ‘Muslim Gokhale’.  Gokhale was admired not only by Gandhi and Jinnah but also by his adversaries and critics like Lokmanya Tilak. Mahatma Gandhi speaking of Gokhale said “pure as crystal, gentle as a lamb, brave as a lion and chivalrous to a fault and the most perfect man in the political field”.

The constant travel, heavy work took a toll on Gokhale’s health. He died on 19th Feb 1915 at the age of 49 years. India was unfortunate to lose a gem so early. Lokmanya Tilak addressed the gathering at his funeral with his famous obituary “diamond of India, this jewel of Maharashtra, this prince of workers is taking eternal rest on funeral ground. Look at him and try to emulate him”. These words express the greatness that was Gokhale.

To Zoom or Not To Zoom

With the lockdown in many parts of the globe, the use of video conferencing service Zoom increased significantly. From an average user base of about 10 million per day in Dec 2019 the service saw 200 million users connecting in March 2020. As the service gained popularity there were reports of the Zoom application being not secure enough. People who were using it faced a dilemma whether to use the app or refrain from using it.

The objections or concerns related to zoom were mainly as follows

  1. Data Privacy Concerns : There were concerns that Zoom retains content enabled for cloud recording, messages and other content shared using Zoom. That the information puts users personal information at risk. Further that Zoom shares information/ integrates with some third party platforms like Facebook and LinkedIn without adequate disclosure. This concern seems to have been addressed by Zoom. There were additional concerns related to data encryption. While the connection from the user is encrypted, the same encryption is not used within the internal network.
  2. Security Concerns : In 2018 a critical security flaw was discovered in Zoom clients. When exploited, it allowed attackers to spoof messages, remove users or highjack shared screens. However this vulnerability has not been reported in the latest versions of Zoom. Few zero day vulnerabilities are reportedly available in the digital underground. A zero day is a flaw which is not known yet or has just been discovered and for which no remediation is available. There were also concerns regarding zoombombing where unauthorised users gatecrash into meetings without being invited.

The above seems quite scary and many users may rightfully be extremely concerned. However before taking a decision on its usage it is quite necessary to understand whether any protection is available. It is important to note that the software related security concerns in the public domain were largely associated with older versions of the application. So if a user has deployed the latest versions or updated the earlier version this risk is addressed.

Zoom also provides users to configure controls like passwords, option to control who joins the virtual meeting, option to ensure that only the host can start the meeting etc. Thus, if the controls provided are configured with due care the risk is further reduced.

Lastly, users need to understand the purpose for which Zoom is being used. It is generally accepted by security professionals that there is nothing that is absolutely secure. Security needs to be seen in the appropriate context. The security requirements for protecting nuclear secrets is not the same as those for protection of publicly available or less sensitive information. Thus when using Zoom users need to be aware of the information that will be exchanged. If the content of the discussion is extremely sensitive or involves official secrets users may want to be cautious. In these cases it is best to use the modes of communication authorised by your organizations. If it is not something that is very sensitive, nor extremely confidential or secret it would be reasonably safe to use Zoom.

Home Composting

Home Composting

Over the last two years our family has been practicing home-composting. Home composting is a method to turn common organic kitchen waste into compost that is nourishing to plants. Our objective behind composting was not primarily about creating high quality compost. The drive was more around finding sustainable solution to common problem of waste disposal. Most Indian cities in including Pune, the city I live in, are desperately fighting a battle for effective waste disposal. The motive was to solve the problem in a limited way for our family at least.

Home composting is like learning to cycle or swim. It is best achieved by trying it out. Within no time you become a master at it. We have used home composter offered by Daily Dump. We opted for it for the elegant looks and easy of storage and use. However large sized garden pots can work just as well and there is no need to specifically buy a composter. We went through the initial doubts and skepticism before we decided to try it out and I thank my stars that we finally did it. Over the last two years no shred of organic kitchen waste has gone into the trash bin. In a tiny way I have ensured that our family has not been a burden on the city when it comes to waste disposal.

We live in an apartment and have no garden. When we began we were skeptical whether we could achieve home composting, since we perceived it as an activity for people with their own gardens. From my personal experience I can vouch that if you have a place big enough to hold a large earthen garden pot or a composter you can easily practice home composting. However be careful to place this pot outside your living space. Home composting is not to be done within the four walls of a room. You can place it in a corner on your terrace, in a balcony, on the landing of your floor, below your stair well or any other reasonably sheltered place. Be sure to have a strong lid that cover the pot or the composter. This ensures that rodents are unable to raid your composter and keeps files away. The lid also ensures that there is no odour that comes from the composter.

The composting process requires three elements – air, moisture and microbes. Air is available for free and it supply can be ensured by moving or churning the contents of the composter with a stick every couple of days. This can be done when you have time and takes no more than a couple of minutes at the most. This ensures air supply to the waste and ensures that no foul odour is emitted. The waste needs to be maintained in a moist condition. Composting stops when the waste turns dry. Similarly if it turns too wet and soggy, the air supply is cut off and the waste starts to purify and emit foul odour. Good compost should have a nice earthy smell. Foul odour is a red flag that says – it’s are going wrong! Most of the times foul odour is on account of lack of air supply or too much of water content. To correct the situation, all you need to do is to churn the waste giving it air to breathe or control the water content. The water content can be controlled by adding coco-peat. This is available in most of the nurseries in the form of a compact brick. The coco-peat is used as potting mixture to grow plants, however we use it in home composting for reducing the moisture inside the composter pot. The coco-peat brick is hard and difficult to break. The trick to breaking off small quantities from it is to pour some water over parts of the brick. The part of the brick that becomes wet comes off and is quite easy to break. The coco-peat brick is not very expensive. Coco-peat is to be used in small quantities – say a few handfuls. The coco-peat brick thus lasts a long time.

The microbes are responsible for the decomposition and composting process. There are plenty of microbes all around us and there is no need to specially add them to the waste. However if you want to hasten the process, microbe cultures are available with most nurseries. I have never felt the need to add microbe cultures from outside and have done the composting without any such additions.

Vegetable peels, fruit and vegetable skin, egg shells, mango seeds, left over food, scraps of non-veg food can all go into the pot for composting. It is advisable to cut small pieces where possible. Larger waste like water melon skin needs to be chopped before you put it in. This ensures that it occupies a lesser volume and also speeds up the composting process.With two years behind us, feel a lot of satisfaction that we have been a part of the waste disposal solution and not a part of the problem! This is easy, does not involve significant cost and creates natural compost for your plants. Try it out and help society.